logo

Khawaja’s Book Revives Sandpapergate Controversy in Australian Cricket

Nasser Hussain did not bother dressing it up. “I think it's a complete mess,” he said – and eight years on from Cape Town, Australian cricket is right back in the storm it thought it had escaped.

Usman Khawaja’s new book has dragged ‘Sandpapergate’ out of the archives and into the headlines again. The former Test batter, part of that infamous Newlands match in 2018, claims the entire dressing room knew about the ball-tampering plan, not just the three men who carried the can: Cameron Bancroft, captain Steve Smith and David Warner, the man widely painted as the chief instigator.

Khawaja also says Cricket Australia never even questioned him at the time, despite the fact he was sitting next to Bancroft in the dressing room, and that he urged the side to front up collectively before being talked down by Smith. One of the most toxic episodes in the modern game suddenly has fresh oxygen.

Hussain: ‘How did nobody say no?’

Speaking on the Sky Sports Cricket Podcast, former England captain Hussain cut straight to the heart of it.

“For the history of the game, people have been trying to work out what to do with cricket balls to make it swing more,” he said, reeling off the old tricks – mints, sweets, scuffing the ball into the ground, Vaseline, dirt in the pocket. That murky grey area has always existed.

This was different.

“How a side thought it was okay to take sandpaper out, how no one before that in a meeting went, ‘I don't think this is okay, I don't think we're doing the right thing’, how they thought they were going to get away with it with all the cameras around, I don't know.”

The act was brazen. The cover-up, in Hussain’s eyes, was worse.

“Then to lie about it after and for Cricket Australia not to speak to every player, not to speak to Khawaja who was sitting next to Bancroft. It just feels like a right mess.

“The team, the baggy green, the mateship and all that stuff – that was what playing Australia was like, so for an Australian team to say, ‘no, it's just those three’ when it was never going to be just those three, is surprising.”

The mythology of the Baggy Green was built on shared responsibility. Khawaja’s version of events cuts against that image – and Hussain knows exactly how damaging that is for a side that once prided itself on unity above all else.

Atherton: Heavy bans, unanswered questions

Michael Atherton, also on Sky Sports duty and currently in Australia ahead of England’s white-ball tour, believes this is the fallout Cricket Australia tried to dodge in 2018 and is now being forced to confront.

Back then, Smith and Warner received one-year bans, Bancroft nine months. The governing body threw the book at them. Yet it never fully closed the case.

“It was almost like the sandpaper was the straw that broke the camel's back,” Atherton said. The scandal, he pointed out, landed on top of a team that had already veered into uncomfortable territory – “slightly out of control, a bit unlikable and with a kind of win-at-all-costs mentality,” as Khawaja describes in his book.

Then came a decision Atherton views as deeply flawed.

“They handed down unbelievably heavy sanctions – I thought hard-to-justify sanctions – and left three players to take the rap. But it left questions unanswered, left the door open for it to come back to haunt them, which it is doing now.”

Cricket Australia chose to move quickly and decisively at the time. Atherton believes they ended up with the worst of both worlds: a punishment so severe it shocked the cricketing public, but an investigation so narrow it failed to convince everyone the full story had been told.

He does not think a fresh inquiry is required now, despite Khawaja’s claims. The damage, in his view, lies elsewhere.

“I do think the particular point about not having people's backs is the thing causing the most disquiet [in the Australia public] and will rumble on for a while yet.”

Trust, once broken, rarely heals neatly. Not inside a dressing room, and not in the stands.

A circus in Perth, and a weary nation

Atherton is expecting the latest chapter to play out in front of the cameras in Perth. Australia’s white-ball captain Mitchell Marsh, the only member of the current ODI squad who played in that Newlands Test, will front a press conference on Thursday that Atherton predicts will be a “circus”.

Usual ODI captain Pat Cummins has been rested, as have Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Starc. All three were involved in the Cape Town Test and, along with spinner Nathan Lyon, issued a joint statement in 2021 denying prior knowledge of the plot. Their absence from this particular media storm feels convenient, even if entirely legitimate within a punishing schedule.

The story has dominated newspapers, podcasts and airwaves across Australia again. Atherton senses a certain fatigue.

“It was eight years ago and there will be a weariness around the story eventually, because it's all over every newspaper, podcast, whatever,” he said.

Weariness, though, is not the same as closure. Not when new voices from inside that dressing room keep challenging the official version.

Cracks on the field to match those off it

This is not just a reputational problem. It arrives at a time when Australia’s Test side looks vulnerable on the pitch as well.

Their first Test series in South Africa since the scandal ended in a 2-1 defeat. Marnus Labuschagne, once the heartbeat of their batting, is out of form and has been dropped for the upcoming home series against New Zealand.

The calendar offers no respite: New Zealand at home, a five-Test tour of India, the day-night 150th anniversary Test against England at the MCG in March, then an away Ashes in June and July. It is a brutal run, even for a settled side.

Atherton sees the strain.

“The schedule is brutal and unforgiving and already there's cracks in that team,” he said. “It doesn't feel as though the team is robust enough to get through this period.

This [the ball-tampering claims] is adding a little bit more fuel to the fire.”

Australia used to stride into such stretches with swagger, armed with depth, certainty and that old sense of mateship Hussain remembered. Now they head into it carrying not just opposition plans and fatigue, but lingering doubts about what really happened in Cape Town and who, exactly, stood by whom.

For a team that once sold itself as the ultimate band of brothers, that is the question that refuses to go away.