Residents Struggle with Junction Oval's Blinding Floodlights
At 10pm in Albert Park, the game isn’t on the field. It’s in the sky.
The Junction Oval’s new floodlights – four 50-metre towers of piercing white LED – cut through the inner-Melbourne night like searchlights. For the people who live across the road, they don’t signal the start of play. They signal evacuation.
John, who lives at 83 Queens Rd, doesn’t go to bed when the lights come on. He leaves home.
Driven out of his own apartment by what he calls “bright as hell” glare, he wanders the streets until the last bulb finally powers down. His blinds are no match. Nor is his body. A degenerative cornea and hyperthyroidism make him acutely sensitive to light. The migraines and headaches are now part of the matchday routine.
“Your home, your safe place where you feel secure, it just feels very violating having these lights on,” he said. He times his return for 11pm, when the towers are finally dimmed and the reflections stop bouncing off his TV and into his bedroom.
Seventeen floors up, Andrew doesn’t just draw the blinds. He reached for sunglasses.
His apartment, with its sweeping view across Albert Park, now “lights up like a Christmas tree” whenever the Junction Oval is in use. Photos taken at night look like sunrise. Every pane of glass throws the light back at him. Blockout blinds barely dull the blaze.
Three floors below, James doesn’t need a scoreboard to know when there’s a wicket or a boundary. The celebration gives itself away. The strobes hit his blinds, flicker through the edges and turn his room into a “disco” before the full glare settles in again.
For months now, this has been the new normal for residents around Cricket Victoria’s headquarters: at least two nights a week, sometimes up to four. Training sessions. Matches. Testing. And, at times, lights blazing when no one seems to be on the field at all.
What began in August as a multimillion-dollar upgrade to broadcast women’s cricket has become, for hundreds of neighbours, a nightly siege.
The rules on paper – and the reality in the windows
On paper, the system is tightly controlled.
The light towers cannot be used after 11pm for broadcast or streamed events, or after 10pm for other events. There’s a 30-minute window after those curfews to let crowds and staff leave safely, with lighting capped at 10 lux. Across a calendar year, the towers are only allowed to operate for 45 days.
Residents say the rulebook and the lived experience don’t match.
They claim the lights have already chewed through almost half that 45-day quota in just a few months, with nights spent on testing, training and matches. They’ve watched the oval lit up when no players are visible. They’ve seen training run under full glare despite the presence of what they describe as “less invasive lights”.
They saw it coming, too.
When the 50-metre structures were first proposed, residents launched a petition on change.org, warning that the LEDs would be a problem in a suburb ringed by high-rise apartments. More than 500 people signed. The project went ahead anyway.
For James, who bought his apartment 12 years ago for its sweeping view of Albert Park, the transformation is brutal.
“They turn the lights on even though it’s daylight savings,” he said. “They turn them on about 6pm and the amount of light that comes through the apartment, even with the blinds drawn. We’re effectively living in a box.”
The light doesn’t just pour through the windows. It ricochets around the room.
“We’ve got glass inside our apartment as well so it reflects off the splashback, the internal glass walls, it’s terrible.”
His family has had to rearrange their lives around the beams. Literally.
“We have dinner at different ends of the table” just to avoid the worst of the glare, he said.
John’s coping mechanism is more drastic. He leaves.
“I literally do not want to be at home when the lights are on,” he said. “Even driving home along Queens Rd, as I’m pulling into the building, I need to have sun visors down in the car because (the lights) are blinding.”
He worries not just for himself, but for anyone with photosensitive epilepsy caught in the path of the unannounced pyrotechnics and strobing.
“Anyone with photosensitive epilepsy could have an episode,” he said. “Who’s actually evaluated that risk? Or who’s taking that into consideration?”
Andrew and his partner had an option many of their neighbours did not. They moved out.
He still owns the apartment and rents it out, but every time he returns to clean or check on it, the view hits him differently.
“I think it’s ruined the beauty of the area,” he said. “Even when I go back there now I just look at it and I’m taken away from the view and beauty of it all.
“But the lights, oh my god, it’s like living next to the MCG. I remember them going in and feeling so violated that we had no control over the four 50-metre-high lights being built right in front of our home.”
Residents say the impact stretches beyond apartment towers. They’re also worried about the effect on “vulnerable” people staying at a nearby homeless encampment.
An audit says it’s fine. Residents say it’s a farce.
On the ground, people are drawing blinds, shifting dinner seats and walking the streets to escape the glare.
On paper, nothing is wrong.
An independent engineering audit, commissioned by Cricket Victoria and submitted to the state government, concluded the Junction Oval towers are “generally compliant” with Australian standards and require “no remedial measures”.
“No material exceedances attributable to the Junction Oval lighting installation were identified, and no remedial measures are considered necessary based on the assessment undertaken,” the Lucid Consulting report found.
The audit did identify two locations on Lakeside Drive where light levels exceeded the 25 lux limit. It pinned those readings on existing streetlights and “mild humidity” scattering light through the air, and dismissed them as unrelated to the oval.
Residents weren’t convinced. Not by the findings, and not by the scope.
They point out the report “made no mention of Queens Rd”, where many of the apartments sit just 50 to 200 metres from the towers. They say testing was conducted at ground level, ignoring the eye-level reality for people living 10, 15, 20 storeys up.
“The report makes no mention of Queens Rd, no mention of the apartment buildings within 50 to 200 metres of the towers and no mention of any measurement of line-of-sight intrusion into surrounding apartments,” James said.
At least eight formal complaints have gone to Cricket Victoria, Port Phillip Council and Parks Victoria. Residents say the responses range from sympathetic words to a shrug of powerlessness.
They also argue the process was stacked against them from the start.
‘This is what we’re doing. Either accept it or…’
Ask the residents about “community consultation” and the frustration spills out.
“There was no concern of what the broader community wanted,” John said.
He recalls a single session with Cricket Victoria. The notice, he says, arrived on the day of the meeting – hand-delivered or dropped into letterboxes with little time to organise or respond.
To him, it felt “very shady”.
As for the meeting itself, the phrase that keeps coming up is “a bit of a farce”.
John remembers asking a simple, pointed question: how comfortable would anyone in the room feel having a street light flash into their bedroom window?
“They kept beating around the bush not giving a straight answer and I literally told them it’s a yes or no answer … we never got anywhere,” he said.
“We had that one consultation session where we said the lights need to be reduced in height and there was no sort of consultation that happened after it. It was sort of like, ‘this is what we’re doing. Either accept it or there’s nothing you can do about it’.”
Cricket Victoria tells a different story.
A spokeswoman said community consultation began in March and April 2025, including direct mail notifications to neighbouring residents and an open forum at Junction Oval. Locals were invited to join a “Friends of Junction Oval” mailing list for project updates.
The towers were ultimately approved not by council, but through a special ministerial planning amendment. It bypassed local government and locked in the 45-day annual cap and curfews.
Within that framework, Cricket Victoria insists it has stayed inside the lines.
Everyone’s responsible. No one’s accountable.
When residents ask who can actually rein in the lights, the answers loop in circles.
Port Phillip Council points to the state.
City of Port Phillip chief Chris Carroll said the towers were approved by the Victorian Government, sit on Crown land and are managed by Parks Victoria.
“While Council has no regulatory role, we have engaged in discussions with Cricket Victoria to advocate on behalf of our community and seek practical solutions to address concerns raised,” he said.
Local MP for Albert Park, Nina Taylor, said her office received “a number of objections” to the proposed light towers in early 2025. She says she forwarded every objection to Cricket Victoria and asked that they be registered as part of the consultation process. She has not publicly addressed the current complaints.
Parks Victoria, the land manager for Albert Park Reserve, did not issue a formal comment. It is understood to hold regular meetings with Cricket Victoria, which provide a forum to raise resident concerns. When asked to respond, Parks Victoria referred questions to the Department of Transport and Planning.
The department said it had worked with Cricket Victoria and Port Phillip City Council “to support improved sporting infrastructure at Junction Oval”.
“Cricket Victoria has submitted an independent assessment of the lighting system, which we’re now reviewing,” a spokesman said.
Cricket Victoria, for its part, has one eye firmly on the cricketing upside.
A spokeswoman said the organisation is working with businesses on Fitzroy Street so “economic opportunities from increased attendances can be realised”.
“Cricket Victoria remains committed to engaging constructively with our local community,” she said.
“The lights have been used for training on a small number of evenings which fall within the approved maximum of 45 nights of use per year.
“It is important for our male and female cricketers to be able to train under evening conditions like our competitors across the country.”
Cricket Victoria did not answer specific questions about how it is managing complaints from residents at 83 Queens Rd.
A battle over brightness with no dimmer switch in sight
For now, the towers stand, the audit stands, and the residents keep drawing their blinds.
On one side is a state-backed sporting body, armed with ministerial approval, compliance reports and a mandate to lift cricket infrastructure to national standards. On the other are locals who say their homes have been turned into lightboxes and their nights into endurance tests.
Impacted residents are now exploring their next move – legal options, fresh complaints, any lever that might force the beams down to a tolerable level.
The lights, they accept, are not going anywhere. The question is whether anyone will turn them down.






