logo

David Warner's Claims on Cape Town Scandal Investigation

David Warner has lit another fuse under Australian cricket’s most toxic saga, claiming three of the country’s premier bowlers were never even interviewed over the Cape Town sandpaper scandal.

On Instagram, Warner alleged Josh Hazlewood, Mitchell Starc and Nathan Lyon were not spoken to as part of Cricket Australia’s internal probe into the 2018 debacle that cost him, Steve Smith and Cameron Bancroft lengthy bans and their reputations.

“As far as I am aware, CA did not interview (them),” Warner wrote.

“If that’s correct, then how can CA push the idea that the bowlers didn’t know?

“It looks like they had decided who they wanted to blame from the very beginning, and ran a shoddy investigation to serve the purpose, and now they want to maintain the false narrative that the bowlers had no idea.

“That stinks of a cover-up.”

Those words cut straight to the heart of a scandal Australian cricket has never fully escaped. They also collide head-on with fresh reporting. The Age, citing two sources with knowledge of the investigation, says Hazlewood, Starc and Lyon were in fact interviewed, directly contradicting Warner’s explosive claim.

The dispute lands in a week when old wounds were already wide open. Warner has been backing Usman Khawaja’s assertion that the Australian Test team knew of a plan to tamper with the ball in Cape Town. Current captain Pat Cummins has publicly rejected that version, insisting he had no idea sandpaper was being taken onto the field.

At the time, Cricket Australia’s formal investigation focused squarely on the on-field plot that played out on television screens around the world. Smith, Warner and Bancroft were hit with heavy sanctions. No other player was charged.

But the questions never really stopped.

CA also commissioned a broader cultural review, led by The Ethics Centre’s executive director Dr Simon Longstaff, to dig into the team’s behaviour and the organisation’s own corporate settings. Longstaff spoke to a range of current and former players, staff, sponsors and other stakeholders.

He says it did not take long for the whispers to start.

“We’re talking effectively about … good people who made bad decisions, so that’s where we looked,” Longstaff said on Nine’s Weekend Today.

“Along the way there were whispers, and I can't put it any more strongly than that, that something else had gone on earlier and that more people had known.”

That hint of a wider circle of knowledge pushed him to probe further.

“When we came to look into that – because I couldn’t turn a blind eye to it once the suggestion was made – I afforded the senior people I spoke with an opportunity … ‘Well, is there something else you want to say about the whole circumstance?’

“Nobody chose to make any alteration to their statement, so I was left with basically a blank wall.

“Some people saying one thing, others another, but not sufficient to be able to say there needs to be a further inquiry at that time.”

Khawaja, in his book Sabr, paints a picture of being ready to break that wall, and never being asked.

He writes that he expected a call from Cricket Australia during the original investigation and believes his stance on “collective blame” cost him a voice in the process.

“I thoroughly feel that I didn’t get interviewed because of that, because they knew that I wanted to take it as a team, because they knew I was ready to tell the truth if I was interviewed,” Khawaja wrote.

“And I was waiting for my phone to ring. It just never rang, and then the penalties were given, and I couldn’t believe it.”

Longstaff says several figures were invited directly to participate in his review and some chose not to. He cannot recall whether Khawaja was specifically among those formally approached, but stresses that everyone had the chance to come forward.

“I can't remember exactly who it was that was given the opportunity to contribute to our review, which went much further than just the players involved,” he said.

“It looked at the whole of Cricket Australia, sponsors, supporters … past Test players to see what the comparison could be. Not everybody we invited to participate in our review chose to accept that invitation. They had the liberty not to.

“Anything they were to say was under strict conditions of confidentiality, which of course, we're bound to respect even to today.”

The human toll, Longstaff says, has been severe.

He describes the entire saga as “deeply upsetting for everyone involved to have their reputations called into question”, from those sanctioned to those still fighting to separate themselves from the stain of Cape Town.

On Friday, Cummins fronted a marathon 70-minute press conference, defending his integrity and flatly denying he knew sandpaper was being taken onto the field. Longstaff watched on and came away convinced.

He called Cummins’ performance “absolutely convincing in his sincerity”.

“That stands against Usman Khawaja's claim that everybody knew, so there's a clear contradiction there,” Longstaff said.

“If Cummins did not know, and I believe he didn't, then not everybody knew. But that leaves a different question.

“Was it that many other people did know, if not Cummins? And is Khawaja being sincere in his belief … that if not everybody, there was a considerably larger number (that knew). Now we just don’t know.

“There’s been consistent denials from the bowling team as a whole, and that stands in contrast now to what Usman Khawaja and David Warner are both asserting.

“To that end, I think, although it’s so messy, there has to be some explanation which could be found. I’ve spent a career looking into questions like this, and inevitably, when you find this kind of conflict of opinion, there is a reason behind it.

“It’s just a question of whether or not Cricket Australia wants to determine what that is.”

Six years on from Cape Town, the scoreboard still doesn’t balance. The bans have been served, careers rebuilt, trophies lifted. Yet the central mystery remains: who knew what, and when?

Warner’s latest broadside, the counter-claims about who was interviewed, and the unresolved clash between Cummins’ denial and Khawaja’s belief all lead back to the same place.

Not to the past, but to a choice for Cricket Australia about how much truth it really wants to live with.