logo

Racing Bulls' Decision on 2025 Line-Up: Tension Between Alan Permane and Liam Lawson

Alan Permane is in no hurry. Liam Lawson can’t afford to wait.

That is the tension running straight through Racing Bulls’ season as the team edges towards a decision that will shape not only its own future, but potentially Red Bull’s driver ladder for years to come.

Racing Bulls slow the trigger

Speaking in Sao Paulo, Permane made it clear Racing Bulls are deliberately resisting the urge to pull the trigger on their 2025 line-up, even with both seats still officially open.

“Time is on our side,” he said, outlining a process that sounds more like a research project than a traditional silly-season scramble. The team is “studying, analysing”, trying to “apply a little bit of science” to a choice that has too often looked impulsive in the Red Bull ecosystem.

Permane stopped short of criticising his employers’ famed young driver programme, but the message was obvious enough. Red Bull has burned through talent before. Racing Bulls don’t want to be the next chapter in that story.

He spoke of “snap decisions” made elsewhere, of drivers not given enough time to settle. This, he insisted, would be different.

“We’re not in a rush to do anything, and I’m very confident the right decision will be made.”

The timeline, though, is beginning to grate. Permane again promised an announcement “in the coming weeks” – the same wording he used before Singapore a month ago. Since then, nothing has been signed off publicly, and Lawson and Arvid Lindblad remain in limbo.

A team torn between two missions

On pure performance, the calculation sounds simple. “The main factors are, as always, pace and speed,” Permane said. That’s “the very first thing we look for.”

Yet Racing Bulls are not a normal midfield team. They exist to compete, yes, but also to serve as the proving ground for Red Bull’s next generation. That dual purpose sits at the heart of the current delay.

“We are here to bring young talent through,” Permane stressed. But he quickly added a crucial caveat: that doesn’t mean “just keep churning young talent through the car”.

Experience has value. A benchmark matters. Racing Bulls want at least one reference point in the garage – someone against whom the raw prospects can be measured. That instantly complicates any choice between promoting another rookie, retaining a known quantity, or reshuffling the deck entirely.

Permane refused to rule out any combination of drivers. Formula 2 contender Nikola Tsolov is in the frame. So are the incumbents. The discussions, he said, are close to being completed, even if he will not commit to a date.

“I’m not going to give you a date, but we’re getting there, and it won’t be long.”

For the man currently ninth in the drivers’ standings, that sounds a lot less reassuring than it does in the team’s meeting rooms.

Lawson’s breakthrough meets a brick wall

Lawson has done almost everything asked of him. He sits ninth in the championship on 83 points, the leading driver outside the top four teams, and he has banked 26 points in the last four races alone. That is the kind of consistency midfield outfits usually build around, not hesitate over.

So when he was asked in Brazil what more he could do, his answer to F1 TV carried a hint of exasperation.

“I don’t know what else they want me to do. But yeah, it’s just one of those things at the moment.”

The calendar offers him no comfort. The closer Formula 1 edges towards the chequered flag on this season, the fewer alternative doors remain open.

“When something like this is pushed all the way to the end, you’re left with not really any options,” he admitted. No Plan B. No safety net.

His performances in Sao Paulo practice underlined the point. Tenth in FP1, 13th in FP2: not headline-grabbing, but solid, tidy, error-free. The sort of days that build trust within a team, even if they don’t dominate the broadcast.

Paddock sympathy, limited power

From the outside, there is little doubt about the job Lawson has done.

Sky Sports F1 analyst Bernie Collins highlighted his role in Racing Bulls’ current fifth place in the constructors’ standings, a position that carries serious prize money and prestige for a team in transition.

“We don’t know what happens in the engineer meetings or what goes on in the background, but definitely from our point of view he appears to have done enough,” Collins said.

Naomi Schiff took the argument a step further, suggesting the decision might already be done and dusted in Lawson’s favour if Racing Bulls were operating as a fully independent outfit rather than as a strategic arm of Red Bull’s wider driver development machine.

“If they managed themselves as their own completely separate entity with their own mission, then maybe he would have done enough,” she said. “But unfortunately that’s just not the setup they have there.”

That is the brutal reality for Lawson. His fate is not being decided solely on what he has delivered in a Racing Bulls car, but also on how the bigger puzzle looks in Milton Keynes and beyond. Who is ready for a future Red Bull seat? Who needs more seasoning? Who fits the long-term political and commercial plan?

The Mexico flashpoint

Into that swirl dropped the Mexico City flashpoint with Max Verstappen. Lawson collided with his former teammate in practice, both men picked up penalties, and the reigning world champion did not hide his irritation, publicly questioning Lawson’s judgement while nodding to his uncertain future.

Lawson apologised. The stewards dealt with it. On track, the matter looked closed.

Off track, the question lingered: could that incident, however minor in the grand scheme, count against a driver already fighting for his place?

Martin Brundle, speaking on Sky Sports F1, was scathing at the very idea.

“If he dared be on the racetrack on a preparation lap like Max at the same moment, if that’s a factor in him getting the heave ho, that’s pathetic,” he said. “That’s so childish. I can’t believe it is.”

Brundle knows what it feels like to lose a seat for reasons that stretch beyond lap time. He referenced his own experience at Benetton, where, as he recalled, he “started to beat Michael Schumacher” and still found himself out at the end of the year.

“It happens in this business for any number of reasons,” he said. “Sometimes commercial reasons, political future, and the teams are thinking a long way ahead and all the pieces of the jigsaw fit together in a way that don’t always look obvious to us standing here talking about it right now.

“But I think Liam’s done a tremendous job for them.”

Science, sentiment and a ticking clock

Permane insists he understands the frustration. He hears it from Lawson. He hears it from Lindblad. He hears it from the outside world. He maintains that both of his drivers are “performing excellently” and even wonders aloud whether the tension is helping to push their level higher.

Maybe, he suggests, they will be “even better when those decisions are made.”

Behind that calm exterior lies a complex equation. Racing Bulls must balance pace with potential, youth with experience, their own results with Red Bull’s grand plan. Permane himself is secure until 2031. Lawson is fighting for the right to be on the grid next March.

One side can afford patience. The other is staring at the end of the season with no Plan B.

The team principal says the call is close. The numbers say Lawson has made his case. The politics, as ever in Formula 1, will decide whether that is enough.