logo

George Russell: Rosberg Route or Ricciardo Road?

George Russell is standing at one of those brutal crossroads Formula 1 specialises in. Two paths, as Karun Chandhok sees it. Nico Rosberg on one side. Daniel Ricciardo on the other.

The Sky Sports F1 analyst believes the next 15 months will define which way the Mercedes driver goes after being, in his words, “pretty beaten up” this year by team-mate Kimi Antonelli.

Rosberg route or Ricciardo road?

Chandhok did not dress it up. For Russell, this phase of his career can mirror Rosberg’s resurgence or Ricciardo’s slow slide away from the sharp end.

On one hand sits the Rosberg template. The German took his punishment when Lewis Hamilton stormed to titles in 2014 and 2015, then came back in 2016 a different animal. Sharper, nastier in wheel-to-wheel combat, mentally ruthless. He turned the tide and walked away as world champion.

“Either George Russell can do a Nico Rosberg and go from 2015 to 2016 and make a step up and take the fight for the world championship, and win the world championship in the following year, having been pretty beaten up this year,” Chandhok said.

On the other hand lies the Ricciardo scenario. Once the clear leader at Red Bull, Ricciardo saw the future arrive in the form of Max Verstappen, a “generational talent” who bent the team around him. Ricciardo chose to leave rather than spend his prime years trying to beat a phenomenon in a car increasingly tailored to someone else.

“Or he could end up in a Daniel Ricciardo situation where he was the established number one in the team, had this young pup Max Verstappen arrive, a generational talent in that Red Bull team, and in the end, he opted to leave.

“He thought, ‘You know what, I can’t beat this guy, so I’m going to go somewhere else and go for Renault’.”

For Chandhok, that is the stark question now creeping into Russell’s world.

“Does he end up in that scenario where he suddenly realises over the next 15 months, ‘No, this is not happening for me. I can’t beat this kid in this team, and I’ve got to start thinking about something else’,” he added.

“I’m interested to see which one he ends up following.”

Mexico as a season in miniature

If one race captured Russell’s year, Chandhok believes it was Mexico City.

That was where Antonelli, just 20 years old, wrapped up the title and became the youngest champion in F1 history. It was also where Russell’s campaign, and its frustrations, played out in fast-forward.

He started on the front row. The platform was there. Then the engine problem hit.

“He started on the front row, had an engine issue, didn’t have power on the opening lap, and all of a sudden he finds himself down in fifth, sixth place,” Chandhok said.

From there, Russell’s race dissolved into a familiar pattern: stuck in traffic, unable to show the pace he felt was in the car, watching a big result slip away.

“It was a frustrating race, just stuck in traffic. It just summed up his weekend, summed up his season, really.”

Not just bad luck

Russell has spoken about how draining this year has been, saying he has only enjoyed six clean weekends all season. Mechanical issues, reliability glitches, and scruffy Saturdays have all taken chunks out of his title challenge.

Chandhok accepts that the balance of misfortune has tilted against the Briton.

“He has had more issues than his teammate, there’s no questioning that,” he said.

But he also drew a clear line: this is not just a story of luck.

“But by his own admission, he’s also not been as fast as his teammate. So I think Kimi Antonelli has won the championship because he’s been the faster Mercedes driver, and Mercedes produced the fastest car across the season.

“And I think he’s won the championship this early in the season, because George Russell has had more bad luck than he has.”

The combination has been lethal for Russell’s hopes: a quicker team-mate, in the same dominant machinery, with fewer problems.

A career on the brink of definition

So the picture is set. A 28-year-old established race winner, bruised by a rising star who has just torn up the record books. A team that has delivered the fastest car. A title gone, and a winter looming that will demand uncomfortable questions and even harder answers.

Chandhok has framed it starkly because that is how it looks in the paddock. Rosberg or Ricciardo. Reinvention or resignation.

Over the next 15 months, Russell will decide which name his own story ends up next to.