logo

Why Is the Republic of Ireland Facing Israel in UEFA Nations League?

Why Is the Republic of Ireland Playing Israel?

Back in February, before the UEFA Nations League draw in Brussels, the Football Association of Ireland (FAI) was bracing for a tough scenario. The Republic of Ireland was placed in Pot 3 for the League B draw, knowing that one of the Pot 1 teams would bring a complicated political and logistical challenge. That team turned out to be Israel. The Republic found themselves in Group B3 with top-seeded Israel, as well as Austria and Kosovo.

Shortly after the draw, the FAI announced they would play both home and away matches against Israel, but neither game will take place in Ireland or Israel. Instead, Ireland’s away match against Israel is set for 27 September in Debrecen, Hungary, and their home fixture will happen on 4 October in the small Serbian town of Backa Topola behind closed doors.

By moving the games to neutral venues far from Dublin and without fans, the FAI may have hoped to avoid controversy. Still, since the draw, many have asked why Ireland is playing Israel at all. Calls to boycott these fixtures have grown louder due to accusations from a United Nations independent commission labeling Israel guilty of genocide in Gaza. These two matches might become some of the most debated involving the Republic of Ireland in recent times.

Coach’s Comments Stir Controversy

Tensions escalated when Ireland’s head coach, Heimir Hallgrimsson, said last week, “We're not playing with genocide, we're playing against genocide.” He clarified, “We're playing against Israel, we're not playing with Israel.” The Israeli government denies the genocide accusations following their response to the October 7 attacks almost three years ago, when Hamas killed about 1,200 people and took 250 hostage. Since then, over 70,000 Palestinians have died in Gaza according to UN figures.

The Israel Football Association condemned Hallgrimsson’s remarks, calling them “stupidity, ignorance and hypocrisy.” Meanwhile, protestors gathered outside the Irish team’s hotel in Dublin on Monday night as part of the “Stop the Game” campaign.

Public Reaction and Political Context

The controversy echoes wider cultural moments such as rapper Macklemore’s removal from Ed Sheeran’s tour after mentioning “free Palestine.” Irish acts Aaron Rowe and folk band Beoga withdrew from the tour in solidarity, showing how these issues resonate beyond football.

Former Republic of Ireland player Kevin Kilbane, who earned 110 caps, wrote that fulfilling these fixtures leaves a “stain” on the FAI. He said, “Ireland should not be playing Israel. Not in Dublin, not in Hungary and definitely not a ‘home’ match in Serbia.”

FAI’s Position and UEFA Response

The FAI wrote to UEFA’s Executive Committee in November, asking for Israel’s suspension from international competitions. They said refusing to play would deeply impact Irish football, risking points in the Nations League and weakening chances for Euro 2028 qualification, which Ireland co-hosts, and future World Cups.

Unlike UEFA and FIFA suspending Russia after its 2022 invasion of Ukraine, Israel has continued competing despite the conflict since October 7. UEFA planned to vote on Israel’s status last year but postponed after ceasefire talks between Israel and Hamas. Since then, over 1,300 Palestinians have died in Gaza, with both sides accusing each other of breaking the agreement.

Other European Teams and Boycott Decisions

No European country has boycotted matches against Israel yet. Pro-Palestinian protests took place before Israel’s World Cup qualifiers in Norway and Italy last season, but neither country forfeited their games. The Norwegian Football Federation president, Lise Klaveness, said, “A boycott would only result in Israel going to the World Cup instead of us.”

Earlier this month, the FAI chief executive David Courell confirmed UEFA denied a request to separate Ireland from Israel in future draws, stating there has never been direct conflict between the two countries.

UEFA’s Safety Measures and Match Coverage

UEFA did approve the FAI’s request to move the home fixture against Israel from Dublin to a neutral venue for safety reasons. No tickets are available for Irish supporters for the away game in Hungary either.

The Republic’s public broadcaster, RTE, will provide limited coverage of the matches, with no studio analysis and commentary sourced from the international feed. Despite empty stands and a stripped-back broadcast, these matches remain highly charged events with strong opposition back in Ireland.

Group B3 Standing

  • Teams: Israel, Republic of Ireland, Austria, Kosovo
  • Match dates: Ireland vs Israel - 4 October (Serbia), Israel vs Ireland - 27 September (Hungary)
  • Venue notes: Both fixtures played away from Ireland and Israel, no spectators allowed