logo

VAR Controversy in Everton's 3-1 Victory Over Coventry

Frank Lampard left Goodison Park shaking his head, not at his team’s effort, but at the officials.

Coventry led, worked, and then watched three major VAR calls go against them as Everton roared back to win 3-1 on Friday night, Thierno Barry scoring twice before Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall killed the game late on. Lampard’s side slipped to 16th in the Premier League. His mood dropped even further.

Hair, hands and a sense of injustice

The flashpoint that set the tone came before the interval. A high ball, a tangle in the box, and James Tarkowski clearly tugging Caleb Yirenkyi’s hair as they jumped.

Coventry players appealed instantly. Referee Stuart Attwell waved them away.

The law on hair pulling has been softened this season. Not every pull is a foul. Not every tug is a red card. Officials are told to consider excessive force and intent. For Lampard, that nuance felt like a shield rather than guidance.

“They're saying it's not enough of a pull and I think it's a hard area to be in. What is a hair pull? You've decided it is but it's not enough,” he said. “I think the rules are fine. It's not a red card. I kind of get that… but I think if the rule remains that it's a foul so I felt it was a foul.”

On this one, Coventry have a case. The law was relaxed to stop automatic red cards for any contact with hair, not to erase fouls in the box. For a penalty, Tarkowski’s actions only needed to be judged as a foul, not violent conduct. There appeared to be a clear movement of his arm towards Yirenkyi’s hair. VAR Timothy Wood stayed silent.

The pressure finally told on Lampard’s touchline composure.

Coventry strike, controversy follows

After the break, Coventry struck first. Yann Gboho finished to give the visitors a deserved lead and, briefly, control. It did not last long.

Lampard, though, was still replaying another moment in his mind. Early in the second half, Taiwo Awoniyi surged towards the area and went down under a clip from Vitalii Mykolenko.

“Taiwo for me on the line of the box is a penalty. You've got to give the foul in real time anyway, the ref did let it go, and I felt it was a penalty,” Lampard said.

Replays showed the contact came outside the box. VAR cannot step in to award a free-kick, only a penalty. With the foul starting beyond the line, there was no intervention. Even if it had been on the edge, it would have taken a bold review to upgrade it.

From Coventry’s perspective, that was two big calls gone.

Barry’s touch, and a season’s fine margins

Then came the moment that truly stung. Barry’s second goal.

The ball flew towards him, appeared to brush his arm and then changed direction before ending up in the net. Nottingham Forest saw a goal chalked off for something similar against Tottenham earlier this season. This time, the outcome was very different.

Lampard was adamant. “The Barry one is handball, I've heard they are saying it didn't touch his hand but I've seen an angle where he has flicked it in with the final touch. VAR is there for that.”

Wood checked it and decided there was no conclusive proof the ball had touched the hand. No offence, no overturn. The goal stood.

Yet the replay angles suggested a slight deviation once the ball made contact with Barry’s arm, the kind of detail VAR exists to catch. Some would argue ruling it out would have been too forensic. Coventry will argue it was exactly the type of handball that should be punished.

Three decisions. Coventry can feel aggrieved about at least two.

Moyes unmoved as Everton climb

On the other bench, David Moyes watched his side climb to fifth and saw the same incidents through a very different lens.

“We've had plenty [of decisions] which have gone against us. It certainly doesn't hit his hand,” the Everton manager insisted, defending Barry over the second goal.

He did, however, side with Lampard on one broader point: the hair pulling law.

“The hair pull rule has changed so it would be a booking if it was but I still think it's ridiculous that rule is in the game. I can't understand why they don't fix this completely because I don't see it as a good rule at all.”

Everton had the goals, the points, and the table position. Coventry left with a sense that the story of the night had been written in the VAR booth.

Lampard did not claim every call had to go his way. He knows the game too well for that. But he also knows that in a season as tight as this, one hair pull, one line on the pitch, one touch on an arm can drag a club towards trouble.