logo

Tuchel’s England Squad Dilemma: A Missing No 9 and Veteran Resurgence

Thomas Tuchel names his latest England squad on Friday, and once again the conversation circles the same problem position: life behind Harry Kane.

Kane has just lifted the Ballon d'Or. He is captain, record goalscorer and the heartbeat of Tuchel’s side. He wants every minute, every game. That leaves the role of understudy as one of the toughest gigs in international football – you must be ready, razor sharp, but you might barely touch the grass.

A Championship No 9 on the Fast Track?

Dominic Calvert-Lewin has been the most recent heir to that thankless job. He has been in and around squads both before and after the World Cup, and his form for Leeds has been respectable. Under Tuchel, though, the chemistry has not quite sparked. Across the last window, he was handed just 15 minutes, spread over two substitute cameos. That is not the footprint of a trusted deputy.

Tuchel has already experimented. Jude Bellingham, of all people, has been used as the back-up to Kane, a sign of both England’s depth in attacking midfield and their shortage of orthodox centre-forwards.

This time, though, the door might open for a very different profile.

Will Lankshear is 21, raw, and playing his football in the Championship. He also cannot stop scoring. Sold by Tottenham to Middlesbrough in the summer for £20m, he has rattled in 15 goals in all competitions this season. Thirteen of those have come in 13 Championship matches, a ruthless streak that has helped drive Boro to the top of the division.

He is not even a seasoned youth international. Lankshear only made his England Under-21 debut in the last international window – and promptly scored. To go from that to a senior call-up in the space of two camps, while still outside the Premier League, would be a dramatic rise.

Tuchel knows exactly who he is. With so few traditional No 9s emerging through the age groups, Lankshear offers something close to a specialist option. And Tuchel has never shied away from a bold selection when the structure of his squad demands it. If he wants a pure penalty-box striker to mirror Kane, there are not many candidates. The Championship’s most lethal finisher is one of them.

Henderson: Debate Rekindled in Blue

On the opposite end of the age spectrum sits Jordan Henderson, a name that rarely slips quietly into an England squad.

The Chelsea midfielder has not pulled on an England shirt since the World Cup, when a fall over an advertising hoarding after the win over Mexico at the Azteca Stadium left him with a broken arm. At 36, many assumed that was the final chapter of his international story.

Instead, his club career has taken a twist. Leaving Brentford for Chelsea, he arrived in west London as the experienced head in a young, ambitious group. After shaking off that arm injury, Henderson has done more than just mentor. He has played.

He strung together five consecutive starts in Chelsea’s midfield, re-establishing himself as a central figure and scoring twice in a win over Bournemouth. Only an injury kept him out of the Blues’ victory over Manchester United.

Inside the camp he remains what he has always been: popular, respected, a standard-setter. On the outside, his name on an England teamsheet has often triggered heated arguments about loyalty, form and the balance of the midfield.

Now, though, the picture is slightly different. He is not a sentimental pick clinging to past glories. He is starting regularly for a Champions League-level club and influencing big games. If Tuchel brings him back into the fold this time, the outcry might be quieter, the case for his inclusion stronger.

New Blood on the Brink

Tuchel’s most intriguing calls could come in the bracket just below the established names – players on the verge of a first cap.

Three potential debutants are in the conversation, including a late bloomer in the shape of Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall. At 28, the Everton midfielder is not a typical “next generation” pick, but his story has its own edge. The Toffees’ No 10 has turned down approaches from the Republic of Ireland as he pursues his ambition of representing England.

On the pitch, he has given Tuchel reasons to look closely. Two goals, two assists across all competitions, and a central role in pushing Everton up to seventh in the league. In a side that has needed composure and craft, Dewsbury-Hall has often supplied both.

Then there is Josh King at Fulham, the teenager who has been hovering on the edge of a breakthrough. The 19-year-old has already travelled with the senior set-up, part of the preparation group in the United States before the World Cup alongside Alex Scott, Ethan Nwaneri and Rio Ngumoha. That trip told him – and everyone else – that he is firmly on the radar.

Since then, King has continued to impress for England Under-21s. Tuchel underlined his progress in his last news conference, admitting the midfielder is close to a senior call-up. King brings energy, intelligence and a feel for big occasions that belies his age. If Tuchel wants to freshen the midfield with a fearless runner between the lines, the Fulham youngster fits the brief.

The question is whether this window, with only two Nations League fixtures, is the right moment to turn promise into a cap.

Palmer Under the Microscope

One player Tuchel already knows well at international level is Cole Palmer. The 24-year-old Chelsea forward sat out all four matches in the previous international window with a minor injury, but his situation is far from straightforward.

England’s medical staff have checked on Palmer again as Tuchel weighs up whether to restore him to the squad. Before that last break, Palmer completed 90 minutes for Chelsea against Brentford, then returned to start the first game after the internationals. He is fit enough to feature heavily for his club.

Tuchel’s comments in September, though, still hang over him. The England manager said Palmer had been “playing with discomfort and pain” and was “missing too many opportunities” when on duty for his country. It was a pointed critique of both his physical state and his end product.

Yet the fact that England’s medics are still tracking him closely tells its own story. Palmer remains a serious option for the games against Croatia and Spain. He offers versatility across the front line, a left-footed threat and a creative spark that Tuchel clearly values, even as he demands more ruthlessness.

Whether Palmer’s name is read out on Friday will be one of the defining moments of this squad announcement – a marker of how hard Tuchel is prepared to push a talented player who has not yet fully convinced in an England shirt.

Big Calls, Thin Margins

So the familiar questions return. Does Tuchel gamble on a Championship striker in red-hot form? Does he reopen the door for a 36-year-old midfielder who refuses to fade away? Does he reward club form for Dewsbury-Hall and King, or keep them waiting a little longer? And does he lean back into Palmer, or send an even sterner message?

For a manager who has never ducked a big decision, this window offers another chance to reshape the edges of his squad. With Croatia and Spain looming, the answers he gives on Friday will tell us plenty about how he plans to carry England through the next phase of this cycle – and who he truly trusts when the stakes rise.