logo

Summer 2026 Transfer Window: Manchester United and Tottenham Struggle While Brighton Shine

Premier League Transfers Summer 2026: Big Spenders Face Early Challenges

The Premier League continued its trend of heavy spending this summer, with clubs pouring large sums into new signings. Despite this, some top spenders are already worried as their investments have not translated into strong performances at the start of the season.

Let's review the major signings from this transfer window and take a closer look at which clubs have hit the mark and which have fallen short.

Manchester United and Tottenham's Midfield Overhauls Falter

Manchester United began their much-anticipated midfield overhaul this summer but have struggled to see positive results. Youri Tielemans, arriving from Aston Villa, has not lived up to the hype, while Carlos Baleba remains sidelined due to an ankle injury and has yet to debut. Another signing, Brazilian Andrey Santos from Chelsea, brought in to replace Casemiro long-term, has underwhelmed.

The 22-year-old Santos started in losses against Hull City and Brighton & Hove Albion and has only logged 42 minutes across other appearances. There is still hope for this midfield group to gel, but the pressure is mounting after a sluggish campaign start.

Meanwhile, Tottenham Hotspur find themselves even deeper in trouble, sitting at the bottom of the table after five matches with two draws and three losses. Having spent over €200 million on midfielders Sandro Tonali and Mateus Fernandes, they were expected to challenge for a top-four spot. Manager Roberto De Zerbi has not yet found a way to maximize their impact, and both players must improve substantially soon.

Defensive signing Jan Paul van Hecke has also struggled to meet the demands of playing for a so-called Big Six club. His poor reading of the game raises questions about Tottenham’s decision to trade Luka Vuskovic for him.

Brighton Outshine Spurs with Smart Signings

Brighton & Hove Albion took advantage of Tottenham’s missteps by acquiring Luka Vuskovic, the Croatian defender who never featured for Spurs but impressed during a loan spell at Hamburg. The 19-year-old has become a regular starter and helped Brighton climb to third place in the Premier League.

Vuskovic’s adaptability across different systems highlights Brighton’s shrewd approach to the transfer market, one that rarely leads to errors.

Brentford’s Eye for Talent Pays Off

Brentford continue their reputation for spotting emerging talents. Their latest summer addition, Mamadou Sangare from Ligue 1’s Lens, has shown promise as a dynamic midfielder. His energetic display on the opening weekend left Tottenham’s revamped midfield struggling to keep up.

Sangare’s ongoing impressive form fuels speculation that Manchester United might regret not pursuing him themselves.

Other Noteworthy Summer Signings

  • James Trafford (Leeds United): Conceded only three goals in five league games, solidifying Leeds’ defense.
  • Jeremy Jacquet (Liverpool): Provided stability to Liverpool’s defense, which had difficulties last season.