logo

Who Might Take Over as Manchester United Manager After Michael Carrick?

Michael Carrick faces growing pressure as Manchester United's poor start to the season continues, now marking eight games without a win across all competitions. The recent 3-0 home loss to Bournemouth deepened concerns after a heavy 4-1 defeat against Como in the Champions League. Fans left Old Trafford in large numbers during the second half against Bournemouth, highlighting the club’s troubles.

The problems extend beyond Carrick himself, as defender Lisandro Martinez noted following the Atletico Madrid loss earlier this month. Still, Carrick appears to be under immediate threat, especially after captain Bruno Fernandes criticized his tactics and was benched for the Bournemouth match.

Despite remaining at the helm for Sunday's loss, the club has begun exploring options to replace him, potentially marking the fourth permanent manager since minority owners Ineos took over football operations. Carrick recently gave a passionate speech about sacrifice, humility, and hard work, emphasizing the club’s values and responsibility.

Potential Candidates to Replace Michael Carrick

Eddie Howe

After stepping away from Newcastle United in the summer, the 48-year-old Englishman is available and highly regarded. Howe transformed Newcastle from relegation-threatened to their best Premier League finish in 20 years, also securing their first domestic trophy in seven decades. His energetic, high-intensity style brought Newcastle twice into the Champions League, a style that could suit Old Trafford. Currently, he is favored by bookmakers to take the role.

Fabian Hurzeler

The 33-year-old German coach has turned Brighton into one of the Premier League's standout teams this season. Brighton’s 3-0 win over Arsenal and their Carabao Cup victory against United at Old Trafford show his tactical prowess. Though admired at United, compensation demands and budget constraints may hinder any move. Hurzeler appreciates the stable environment at Brighton, unlike the current turmoil at United.

Hurzeler said: "I'm fully focused on my job here. I have great respect for Michael Carrick and what he’s done at Manchester United. I’m privileged to be part of Brighton's journey, and we’re not finished yet. Building strong connections takes time, and it’s a people business."

Julian Nagelsmann

The former Bayern Munich and RB Leipzig coach was considered earlier in the year after Ruben Amorim's departure. At 39, he remains an attractive option, with a connection through United’s director of recruitment, Christopher Vivell, who worked with him at Red Bull. Nagelsmann might be keen to manage a club of United’s stature.

Unai Emery

Emery’s success at Aston Villa includes Europa League glory and Champions League qualification. Villa are still rebuilding, and Emery enjoys full control over the project, a freedom unlikely at United. Also, with a contract until 2029, Villa would demand compensation that may exceed United’s budget. Emery seems motivated by the challenge at Villa and may hesitate to leave.

Antonio Conte

The Italian coach’s demanding style contrasts with United’s recent passivity. Conte has a history of reviving struggling teams, demonstrated when he brought Tottenham back into the Champions League. His record includes Serie A titles with Juventus, Inter Milan, Napoli, and a Premier League title with Chelsea. However, his sharp criticisms of club management, seen during his Tottenham exit, raise questions about potential conflicts at United.

Conte stated: "Following a successful spell at Napoli, I will carefully consider when to return to management. Reports about financial demands or requests for full control are unfounded; there is no concrete basis for these assessments."

Cesc Fabregas

The former midfielder is building a reputation as a promising young coach, shown by Como's recent Champions League qualification and notable victory over United. He owns a stake in Como and seems committed to the club’s project, making a move to United less likely in the short term. His stock is rising, and a future at one of his former clubs like Barcelona could appeal.

Another Interim Solution?

Manchester United has frequently turned to former players as interim managers, including Darren Fletcher, who led the team for two matches after Ruben Amorim's dismissal. Other past caretakers include Ruud van Nistelrooy and Ole Gunnar Solskjaer. There is no shortage of former players ready to step in and remind the squad of the club's traditions. Fletcher might soon be called upon again if United opts for another temporary fix.