NWSL Players Win Battle Over High Impact Player Rule
The NWSL’s most controversial roster rule has been ripped up and rewritten – and this time, the players won.
In a significant settlement announced on Friday, the NWSL and the NWSL Players Association agreed to strip away the restrictive criteria around the High Impact Player (HIP) rule, opening the door for any player in the league to earn its top salaries. What began as a mechanism to keep stars from bolting to Europe had turned into a flashpoint over control, classification, and who gets to decide a player’s worth.
Now, the labels are gone. The money is not.
From “Rodman Rule” to open market
The HIP rule arrived late last year with big numbers and bigger questions. It allowed clubs to spend an extra $1m above the salary cap to sign or retain star talent – a crucial tool in a league where the 2026 cap is set at $3.7m and European clubs face no such restrictions.
But the catch was always the list.
To qualify as a High Impact Player, athletes had to tick at least one of eight boxes. US national team minutes. Ballon d’Or recognition. NWSL Best XI honors. Placement on media lists such as the Guardian’s Top 100 or rankings built on “marketability.” On paper, it looked like a star system. In practice, it carved the locker room into categories and left some of the league’s best on the wrong side of the line.
Roughly 100 players met the bar when the rule landed, including Trinity Rodman and Sophia Wilson. Yet the criteria would have shut out others, among them two-time NWSL MVP Sam Kerr and US forward Catarina Macario. That contradiction became the heart of the fight.
The NWSLPA filed a grievance, arguing the system violated federal labor law and the existing collective bargaining agreement. At issue wasn’t just who got paid, but who got to be defined as “high impact.”
The league pressed ahead anyway. The board of governors ratified the rule, and it officially took effect on 1 July. Around the league, it quickly picked up another name: the “Rodman Rule.”
The Rodman flashpoint
Rodman sat at the center of this saga from the beginning.
With European clubs circling and willing to offer salaries the Washington Spirit could not match under the cap, the 22-year-old forward became the test case for what the NWSL wanted to be: a league that keeps its stars or a league that watches them leave.
In November, before the HIP rule even existed, the Spirit tried to lock Rodman down with a backloaded deal averaging more than $1m a year. NWSL commissioner Jessica Berman stepped in and blocked it, ruling that the contract violated league rules. The NWSLPA responded with a grievance on Rodman’s behalf, calling the move a “flagrant violation” of free agency rights.
Weeks later, the league unveiled the HIP rule.
The timing was impossible to ignore. The mechanism that would soon be nicknamed after Rodman arrived right on the heels of the league shutting down her record offer. By January, with the new rule in place, Rodman re-signed with Washington on a deal worth more than $2m annually – a landmark contract in the NWSL era.
Yet the grievance over the initial refusal of her contract stayed alive. The union wanted more than a workaround. It wanted structural change.
Criteria scrapped, power rebalanced
That change is now on the books.
Under the settlement, the old eligibility criteria are gone. Starting 1 January 2027, clubs will be able to designate any player as a High Impact Player, provided that player’s salary is at least 12% of the base salary cap. The league retains the right to cap the number of HIP designations per team, preserving some control over spending patterns, but the gatekeeping over who “qualifies” has ended.
In practical terms, that means no more reliance on award lists, media rankings, or national team status to unlock top-tier money. If a club believes a player is worth that slice of the cap, it can pay her like it.
The settlement stretches beyond the HIP rule itself. Six grievances in total were resolved, including the Rodman contract dispute and a challenge to the league’s footwear policy.
That footwear fight might sound minor next to multimillion-dollar contracts, but inside locker rooms it mattered. This season, players received warnings and fines for wearing cleats from brands outside the league’s official sponsors. For athletes whose personal endorsement deals help bridge the gap in earnings, that policy cut directly into their income and autonomy.
Under the new agreement, the league will honor most pre-existing endorsement deals and withdraw previous fines. It’s a small line in a legal document, but a clear signal that players’ commercial identities won’t be so tightly policed.
New rules of engagement
The settlement also changes how the league can wield its authority over contracts.
The NWSL still has the power to reject deals it believes are designed to circumvent the salary cap. That safeguard remains. What changes is the transparency around those decisions. From now on, if the league knocks back a contract, it must notify the union and provide an explanation within 72 hours.
Alongside that, the NWSL will be required to give clubs regular updates on salary cap figures and league revenue throughout the year. In a competition growing as quickly as this one, those numbers shape every roster decision. Keeping them behind closed doors only fueled mistrust.
Now, the framework is clearer. Clubs know the financial boundaries. Players know the mechanisms available to them. The union knows when and why the league intervenes.
The HIP mechanism itself has already reshaped some rosters, even under the old criteria. Teams are not obligated to reveal who holds HIP status, but several marquee players who would have qualified have signed or re-signed in recent months, including Denver’s Lindsey Heaps, Orlando’s Barbra Banda and Gotham’s Rose Lavelle. Their deals hinted at the scale of money that could flow once the system loosened.
The question was always whether that money would be controlled by a checklist or by the open market within the cap. The answer, from 2027, is now clear.
A league growing up in public
This agreement lands in a league still defining itself. Expansion, investment, and record attendances have pushed the NWSL into a new financial tier, but its labor structures have been playing catch-up.
The HIP battle exposed that tension. A rule designed to stem the exodus of stars to Europe instead sparked a confrontation over labor rights, competitive balance, and the optics of ranking players by “marketability.”
By settling, the NWSL and NWSLPA have done more than resolve a single dispute. They have redrawn the boundaries of power in a league where, for years, players had little leverage and less information.
The next phase will test how far that shift really goes. When the 2027 season kicks off and clubs can freely tag any player as a High Impact Player so long as the money matches, we’ll see which teams truly intend to spend, which stars stay, and how long Europe can keep luring away the game’s biggest names.






