logo

Michael Carrick or Eddie Howe: Who Should Lead Manchester United Next?

Michael Carrick vs Eddie Howe: Choosing the Right Leader for Manchester United

Manchester United faces uncertainty as discussions swirl around the future of Michael Carrick, with Eddie Howe emerging as a possible replacement. Paul Parker, a former Premier League champion and ex-Red Devils defender, shared his thoughts on who should guide the team forward.

Carrick’s Early Impact as Interim Manager

When Manchester United appointed Michael Carrick in mid-January following Darren Fletcher's caretaker spell, hopes rose. Carrick, a player known for winning trophies at Old Trafford, made an immediate impression. His first matches included a derby victory over Manchester City and a win at Arsenal, the team that would become champions.

Current Challenges and Contract Questions

Though Carrick led United to a third-place finish last season, the club did not invest heavily in the summer transfer window. This lack of reinforcement shows in this season's results: just two wins from nine games across all competitions and a run of five games without a victory. Speculation about Carrick's future is intensifying, with the club’s leadership reportedly considering a change. Meanwhile, Eddie Howe, recently departed from Newcastle after nearly five years, is thought to be a candidate but might not remain available for long.

Paul Parker’s Take: Stick with Carrick for Now

“I still think you stay with Carrick,” Parker told GOAL. “If you look at Eddie Howe’s situation, he faced tough challenges before. Would he want to step into something similar? He likely won’t get the spending power he needs or bring in his trusted staff. The current environment at Manchester United isn’t ideal for someone ambitious.”
“Winning the league at United would cement a manager’s place in history, like at Liverpool. But right now, it just doesn’t seem possible given the circumstances. The club struggles to move players on and buying isn’t balanced with selling.”
“Eddie Howe will want the right opportunity with people who share ambition. Everyone expects a manager at Manchester United to challenge for the title, but at this moment, the support and structure aren’t there. People were quick to make judgments without fully understanding what’s happening inside the club.”

Manchester United’s Current State and Upcoming Tests

United remains without a Premier League title since Sir Alex Ferguson’s retirement in 2013. Off-field and on-field issues continue to hamper progress. The Red Devils exited the Carabao Cup early this season and sit 13th in the Premier League with six points from six games. Their recent 2-0 loss to Atletico Madrid in the Champions League added pressure, especially after a red card for Leny Yoro and a critical post-match reaction from Lisandro Martinez.

As Carrick fights to keep his job, United prepares for a crucial away match against Leeds at Elland Road this Sunday.

  • Next match: Leeds vs Manchester United
  • Date: 18 October 2026
  • Time: 16:00 (local)