What Led to Michael Carrick’s Struggles at Manchester United?
Michael Carrick’s time as Manchester United manager appears to be nearing its end after a humiliating 4-1 loss against Como in the Champions League. This defeat not only adds to a string of poor results this season but also tarnishes the club’s proud European legacy.
Following the match, the 45-year-old ex-midfielder acknowledged the gravity of the situation by apologizing to the traveling Red Devils fans near Lake Como, signaling his awareness of the mounting pressure on his role.
Where Did Things Go Wrong?
The biggest issue with Carrick’s approach this season has been the team's passivity. This marks a clear departure from the more assertive tactics he employed during his interim spell last season.
Data from MarkStats reveals that last season Manchester United ranked sixth in the Premier League for limiting opponents’ build-up passing success outside the final third, standing at 80.4%. Although part of those numbers includes the period under Ruben Amorim, it suggests the team applied decent pressure then.
This season, the opponent pass completion rate has increased to 83.1%, dropping United to 14th in the league. While not disastrous alone, the real problem lies in their failure to recover possession. The Red Devils are generating only 16.7 turnovers per game in the attacking third—third-worst in the Premier League and ninth-worst across Europe's top five leagues.
Simply put, Manchester United rarely challenge or disrupt their opponents' play either high up or near their own goal, allowing rivals too much freedom.
Defensive Weaknesses
Manchester United’s defense has been consistently poor. They’ve managed just one clean sheet so far this year, which came against Azerbaijani side Sabah in the Champions League opener. In seven Premier League matches, they have conceded 10 goals without keeping a single clean sheet and have allowed two or more goals six times across all competitions.
While expected goals against place them somewhat better than their raw conceding stats suggest, the chances they do concede are often high quality, and opponents are capitalizing.
Conceding four goals to Como away makes it difficult to see how Carrick’s team can bounce back quickly. This defense may simply reflect who they are now.
Insufficient Squad Depth
The squad’s limitations extend beyond coaching. Injuries have piled up, with key players like Manuel Ugarte sidelined long-term due to an ACL injury. Others such as Marcus Rashford, Luke Shaw, and Lisandro Martinez missed the Como game. Benjamin Sesko also recently suffered a lengthy layoff.
The bench for the Como match featured Karl Darlow, Tom Heaton, Daniel Armer, Jayden Kamason, Jack Fletcher, Tyler Fletcher, and Tynan Thompson—all unused substitutes. Players who came off the bench included Carlos Baleba, Amad Diallo, Joshua Zirkzee, Harry Amass, and Shea Lacey. For a club aiming at the Premier League and Champions League success, this depth is inadequate.
Summer signings Andrey Santos and Youri Tielemans started but failed to impress, with Tielemans attracting criticism for his performances.
Last season, Carrick could manage the squad effectively with fewer matches each week, but this season’s added European fixtures have overwhelmed the limited resources, leaving him struggling from the start.
Who Might Replace Carrick?
If Manchester United decide to part ways with Carrick soon, especially following upcoming games against Bournemouth and Chelsea, several candidates are being discussed.
- Eddie Howe: Currently unattached after leaving Newcastle, though no confirmed reports link him directly to the role.
- Antonio Conte: Has Premier League experience but left Tottenham abruptly amid personal reasons.
- Julian Nagelsmann: A talented German coach with no previous experience outside Germany; recently dismissed by the national team after a disappointing World Cup.
- Kieran McKenna: Managed Ipswich Town but would be stepping into his first major club role.
Gareth Southgate has expressed no interest in returning to club management, while Brighton's Fabian Hurzeler would be a tough midseason appointment given his current form.






