logo

Mauricio Pochettino Takes Charge of Manchester United Amid Crisis

Mauricio Pochettino will walk out at Anfield next Sunday as Manchester United manager, ending his brief but eventful spell in charge of the US men’s national team and stepping straight into one of the most combustible jobs in world football.

His move from the US to Old Trafford has been confirmed, with a two-and-a-half-year contract signed to replace Michael Carrick, who was sacked on Thursday after presiding over United’s worst start to a season in 40 years. One win in 11 league games. A place in the relegation zone. This is the scale of the mess Pochettino inherits.

Before he can touch a cone at Carrington, though, he has unfinished business. Pochettino will lead the US through a pair of Concacaf Nations League fixtures on Saturday and Tuesday, finishing with a late-night game against Haiti that will effectively close his chapter in American soccer. Only then does the United era begin.

United gamble on a builder, not a firefighter

United’s hierarchy moved quickly once it became clear Carrick’s position was untenable. Pochettino was identified early, and they never deviated. No drawn-out carousel, no shortlist leaking out over weeks. Despite external interest in Eddie Howe and Julian Nagelsmann, United only held formal talks with one man.

The leadership group at the club settled on Pochettino and had the appointment signed off by Sir Jim Ratcliffe this week. They were sold less on a short-term bounce and more on his reputation for constructing environments: his work at Southampton, his transformative spell at Tottenham, his insistence on culture, clarity and player development.

After the Carrick experiment, United wanted experience. They wanted a coach with a defined footballing identity and a track record of improving players. Pochettino fits that brief. Whether he can impose that structure on a fractured dressing room in crisis is another matter entirely.

The club have paid a heavy price to get him. Pochettino only signed a new four-year deal with US Soccer in August, a broad agreement that gave him deeper influence over youth development and the direction of the men’s programme. United have handed the US federation around $10m (£7.5m) in compensation, plus an additional fee to secure his long-time assistants.

United’s players not away on international duty were told on Thursday they did not need to report back until next week. With the US’s second game against Haiti finishing in the early hours of Wednesday GMT, Pochettino is expected to take his first United session on Thursday. Three days later, Liverpool away. No soft landing. No grace period.

A complicated legacy with the USA

Pochettino leaves the US job with a résumé that can be read two very different ways.

Hired in September 2024 to guide the US through their first home World Cup in 32 years, he put together a 21-12-2 record and reached the last 16. On paper, those numbers stand up well against his predecessors. On the pitch, there were genuine highs. The group stage at the World Cup was hailed as the best in US men’s history, lit up by a 4-1 dismantling of Paraguay that will be remembered as a benchmark performance.

That optimism did not survive the knockout round. A 4-1 defeat to Belgium in the last 16, compounded by the storm around Folarin Balogun’s red card and the federation’s – and Pochettino’s – handling of the controversy, wiped away much of the early goodwill. The scars from that night lingered.

There were other bruises. A shock fourth-place finish in the 2024-25 Nations League. A painful Gold Cup final defeat to Mexico in 2025. Heavy losses in friendlies against elite opposition that exposed a gap the US still have to close. Pochettino’s man-management, usually one of his strengths, did not always land. His relationship with Milan midfielder Christian Pulisic never quite clicked, while Juventus midfielder Weston McKennie drifted in and out of the picture, symbolic of a squad that never felt entirely settled.

Yet the tenure was not devoid of progress. Across his time in charge, 75 players earned at least one cap. After signing his extension, Pochettino used a four-match international window to blood more than a dozen newcomers, and the US went unbeaten across those four games. He leaves behind a broader, more experienced pool, and a sense that the foundations for the next cycle are at least partially laid.

On Friday, he spoke with clear affection about the role he is now leaving behind.

“The opportunity to represent the USA crest was one of the greatest honours of my career. We are so grateful to the players for their commitment, to the fans for their belief, and to the federation for always supporting our staff and creating the opportunities to impact the culture of soccer in this great country,” he said.

“We want to thank Cindy Parlow Cone, JT Batson and Dan Helfrich for their partnership and incredible working relationships throughout our time here. There is tremendous talent in the US player pool from the youth teams through to the senior team, and it’s one of the reasons we have so much belief for the future of US Soccer. You will always have a special place in our hearts, and we will be supporting the teams whenever they step on the field.”

In his absence, continuity will be entrusted to Steve Cherundolo. The US U-23 head coach will take charge of the senior team’s December camp, which is expected to feature a squad built largely from Major League Soccer.

Old Trafford awaits – and so does a restless dressing room

If the US job gave Pochettino scope to shape a long-term project, Manchester United demands instant triage.

United are not only losing matches; they are losing their sense of themselves. The dressing room has been fractious, and the captain sits at the heart of one of the thorniest issues awaiting the new manager.

Bruno Fernandes has turned down a second offer of a new contract, even as the club insist they remain confident of tying him down. The 32-year-old’s current deal runs until the end of the season, though United hold an option to extend it by a further year. If they do not trigger that clause before January, Fernandes will be free to talk to clubs abroad about a summer move.

The interest is real. Saudi Arabia has looked at him before, and Galatasaray have also been linked. Last season, Fernandes was the creative heartbeat of a side that finished third, winning the Professional Footballers’ Association men’s player of the year award and setting a new league record with 21 assists.

This year, his influence has waned. His form has dipped, his frustration has grown. After last month’s Champions League defeat by Como, he publicly criticised Carrick’s tactics, a rare but telling breach of dressing-room protocol from the captain.

Pochettino must decide quickly what Fernandes will be under him: cornerstone, lightning rod, or asset to be cashed in. The answer will shape not just the team’s football but the power dynamics inside a squad that has too often looked rudderless.

The Argentine arrives with a reputation for demanding intensity, unity and sacrifice. At Tottenham, players bought in and careers took off. At Paris Saint-Germain, the politics and egos made that buy-in harder to achieve. Old Trafford, in its current state, could tilt either way.

What is certain is that there will be no time to ease in. His first week will be a blur: a farewell to the US, a transatlantic flight, a first day at Carrington on Thursday, then straight into one of the defining fixtures of any United manager’s reign.

Liverpool away, with United in the relegation zone and the fanbase desperate for a new direction. For Pochettino, it is the sharpest of tests. For United, it is the bet that this time, finally, they have chosen the right man to lead them out of the wilderness.