Mauricio Pochettino's Challenge: Manchester United vs Liverpool
Mauricio Pochettino walks into the fire, not through the side door.
Manchester United’s new head coach has barely had time to find his parking spot at Carrington and already his first assignment is Anfield, on a Sunday afternoon, with Liverpool building a head of steam and United stuck in a relegation fight. No easing-in period, no gentle home debut. Straight into the cauldron.
United arrive on Merseyside in a mess. Ten Premier League games, one win – and that against newly promoted Ipswich Town. Five draws, four defeats, 19 goals conceded. Eighteenth in the table. This is not the version of the club Pochettino imagined when he first flirted with the idea of Old Trafford years ago. His first job is brutally simple: drag United away from the bottom three.
He must do it against a Liverpool side that smell opportunity. Under Andoni Iraola, they are sharpening up, quicker in transition, more confident with every passing week. There is already talk of an outside title push. Anfield will not be patient, it will be expectant.
So how does Pochettino set up a fragile, underperforming United side to survive – and maybe more than survive – in that environment?
Familiar shape, new edge?
The pragmatic answer is that he does not rip everything up. Not yet.
Michael Carrick’s preferred 4-2-3-1, with a mid-block and sporadic pressing from the front, is likely to remain the base. Pochettino has always valued structure and repetition; this is not the week to introduce chaos for the sake of ideology.
Senne Lammens is locked in as No.1. The real surgery is at the back. Nineteen goals conceded in 10 league games is not a blip, it is a trend, and Pochettino has to decide whether to lean into youth or cling to experience.
On paper, Diogo Dalot and Noussair Mazraoui fight it out at right-back, but the more intriguing question lies in the middle. Ayden Heaven and Leny Yoro offer raw legs and recovery pace, a glimpse of a future United built on fearless defenders willing to defend high and aggressive. Teenager Harry Amass is the only specialist left-back with Luke Shaw injured, and his inclusion would be a statement that the new manager is unafraid to trust youth on the biggest stage.
Yet the more likely version of Pochettino, this early, is the one who challenges his senior players to prove they belong in his project. Harry Maguire, Lisandro Martinez and Matthijs de Ligt form a more orthodox pool of centre-backs. They know this league, they know this fixture, and they know this is their audition.
On the left, Patrick Dorgu could edge out Amass despite his defensive question marks. Pochettino has often tolerated a slightly loose full-back if the trade-off is energy and thrust going forward. At Anfield, that risk-reward equation becomes far sharper.
Midfield security before anything else
Long term, Pochettino will want his United to run harder and longer than anyone else. His best teams suffocate opponents with repeated sprints and relentless pressure. But that version of United is months away, not days.
For now, the priority is to stop the bleeding in midfield.
Youri Tielemans offers calm on the ball and positional discipline without it. Alongside him, Kobbie Mainoo is the kind of young, tactically flexible midfielder Pochettino tends to mould into a centrepiece. Mainoo can receive under pressure, shuffle across to cover full-backs, and still break lines with his passing. That double pivot, if it starts, is about control and angles rather than fireworks.
Keeping the 4-2-3-1 means the big calls come in the band of three and at centre-forward.
Bruno Fernandes will take up his usual role as the No.10, the creative hub and emotional barometer. Wide of him, Matheus Cunha is well-placed to start from the left, offering work-rate and link play that Pochettino values, even if it pushes Marcus Rashford towards the bench on a day when his pace on the break could be priceless.
Up front, the puzzle piece is Joshua Zirkzee. If he leads the line, Bryan Mbeumo can shift back to his natural right side, where his direct running and early deliveries can hurt a Liverpool backline that will push high. There is also the option of using Mbeumo centrally and finding room for Amad Diallo on the right, giving United an extra technician between the lines.
These are not new dilemmas. Carrick wrestled with the same combinations and never found a consistently convincing answer. Pochettino’s task is to cut through that uncertainty and pick a structure that will stand up to Anfield’s intensity.
One plausible XI in the familiar shape could look like this: Lammens; Dalot, Yoro, Maguire, Dorgu; Tielemans, Mainoo; Diallo, Fernandes, Cunha; Mbeumo.
Or a bolder gamble?
There is another side to Pochettino. The one that is willing to bend his system to the opponent when the threat demands it.
He knows all about United’s defensive frailties. He also knows what is coming from Liverpool. Cody Gakpo, Florian Wirtz, Alexander Isak, Bradley Barcola, Rio Ngumoha – different profiles, same underlying danger. Pace, sharp movement, rapid combinations. Leave spaces, and they will find them.
One answer is to shut those spaces down at source.
A switch to a 3-4-3, with wing-backs dropping into a back five without the ball, would tighten the gaps between defenders and limit the channels Liverpool’s forwards love to exploit. It is not alien to this squad. Under Ruben Amorim, United flirted with a similar idea, though Bruno Fernandes often found himself shunted into uncomfortable zones, his influence dulled by defensive duties.
Pochettino may still revisit that blueprint. With an extra centre-back, United could crowd Liverpool’s front line, force them wide, and rely on speed in transition to hit back.
In that scenario, Lammens would sit behind a trio of Yoro, Maguire and Martinez. Dalot and Dorgu would operate as wing-backs, dropping deep when Liverpool build but sprinting out when United break. Mainoo and Tielemans would patrol the centre, plugging holes and launching counters. Ahead of them, Mbeumo, Fernandes and Cunha would form a fluid front three, rotating positions to drag Liverpool’s defenders into unfamiliar territory.
On paper, it looks more secure. On the pitch, it demands discipline and concentration that United have not consistently shown this season.
A possible 3-4-3, then: Lammens; Yoro, Maguire, Martinez; Dalot, Mainoo, Tielemans, Dorgu; Mbeumo, Fernandes, Cunha.
Underdogs with everything to prove
Whatever Pochettino decides, United will walk out at Anfield as clear underdogs. Liverpool have the form, the momentum, the crowd. United have a new manager, a bruised squad and a league table that does not lie.
But this is where reputations shift. A disciplined, defiant performance – even without the perfect result – could mark the start of something more stable, more serious, more like a Pochettino team.
The question now is simple: does this become the day United’s season finally turns, or another chapter in a story that is starting to look dangerously familiar?






