Maresca's Tactical Dilemma: City’s Struggles and Defensive Woes
Enzo Maresca walked into the City Ground press room looking less angry than faintly offended, as if football itself had broken some private agreement. Seven wins to start the season, now three defeats on the spin. That sort of swing barely exists in English football history; only Sheffield Wednesday in 1904-05 have ever done it in the top flight.
The numbers say one thing. The pattern on the pitch says something far more troubling.
Control without control
Maresca clung to the statistics. They are, on the surface, persuasive.
- At Aston Villa: 63% of the ball, 15 shots to eight. Lost 2-1.
- Against Brighton: 62% possession, 21 chances to seven. Lost 1-0.
- At Nottingham Forest: a staggering 79% of the ball, 12 chances to 11. Lost again.
On paper, this looks like a side being punished by variance. A few missed chances here, a couple of slips there. City can argue that on most days those games tilt their way. Forest could counter with their own data: third in the expected goals table going into the weekend, second-bottom in the actual one. They were due a correction. City, perhaps, were due a slap.
But buried beneath all that possession is a statistic Maresca cannot talk away. City have not kept a clean sheet since that statement win at Anfield after the last international break. Nine games ago. The match before that, they conceded three against Sunderland. Seventeen goals shipped in the last eight.
You can blame three of them, at least in part, on Gianluigi Donnarumma’s errors. That still leaves a leak that looks less like bad luck and more like bad design.
A high line, and nowhere to hide
Maresca’s teams live and die on the edge. He likes a high defensive line, he wants the ball, he wants control. To make that work, the duels have to be won. The moment they aren’t, the whole structure shakes.
Lose possession, and the back four suddenly stand exposed with grass yawning behind them. That is risky against anyone. It becomes reckless when the centre-forward is Liam Delap in this sort of mood: running the channels, bullying defenders, playing with the energy of a striker who has remembered exactly who he is after a year and more of frustration.
Maresca looked genuinely aggrieved at how his players were outfought in that first half at the City Ground. This wasn’t just a tactical puzzle; it was physical. Forest saw the space, smelled the weakness, and ran through it.
Yet the midfield he selected all but invited that battle.
The price of artistry
City did not spend £125m on Enzo Fernández to leave him on the bench. Maresca plainly adores him. The club’s hierarchy backed that conviction, paying Chelsea a fee that screamed “centrepiece”.
Fernández is a superb footballer. He passes between lines, dictates rhythm, sees pictures others don’t. What he does not bring, at least by Premier League standards, is imposing physicality. Chelsea discovered that when he and Cole Palmer played together. The ball sparkled, but the team often sagged in the fight.
Maresca’s answer at Stamford Bridge was to contort the system around him. Malo Gusto was asked to operate as a hybrid right-back and No 10, an awkward compromise born from a coach trying to protect his structure while indulging his most gifted technician.
Now City feel the same strain.
Rayan Cherki is another luxury you want on the pitch. An outrageously talented attacking midfielder, capable of sliding passes and drifting into pockets that tear open defences. But when the ball is lost, he is unreliable: his positioning loose, his tracking inconsistent, his frame too easily overpowered. Pep Guardiola flagged that last season. It has not changed.
You can carry that sort of player if the platform behind him is built for the fight. Two mobile runners, one shuttling like Elliot Anderson, the other a holding midfielder with the authority and bite of Rodri. That was the idea.
Rodri is gone. Fernández, for all his qualities, does not replace that presence. The burden falls on Anderson to cover too much ground, to plug too many gaps. If he is bypassed by a quick break, or a defender coughs up possession in a bad area, City’s midfield vanishes in an instant. What remains is a high line, a lot of grass, and opponents suddenly licking their lips.
A break that may not feel like one
Maresca welcomed this international break. He called it one of those rare moments when a team is better off not having a quick chance to “put it right”. He wants time. Time to reassess, redraw, maybe even rip up some cherished ideas.
There are obvious fixes. Stop pairing Fernández and Cherki. Add more steel, more legs, more cynicism. Accept that you cannot always have every artist on stage at once.
But the calendar adds a darker twist. When the Premier League resumes, City’s season could look very different – not just in terms of the title race, but in terms of their very place in the division.
It was during the last international break that the independent panel ruled City guilty on all but one of the charges brought by the Premier League. There is a growing belief that the sanctions could drop during this one. The size of any points deduction remains guesswork, but the cloud is real, heavy and permanent.
No one can say with certainty how that hangs over a dressing room. At first, it can fuel defiance. Us against the world. Then, as weeks pass and whispers harden into expectation, defiance can curdle into resignation. That half-second you need to win a duel, that extra sprint to close a runner, can disappear when the mind starts to wonder what any of it will count for.
Maresca’s problem is clearly tactical. It may also be psychological. And until City fix both, the numbers he clings to will keep telling the same brutal story.






