logo

Manchester United in Talks with Pochettino as Carrick Faces Judgment Day

Manchester United have opened formal talks with USA head coach Mauricio Pochettino as Michael Carrick stands on the brink, with his future to be decided at a high‑level summit in Monaco on Wednesday.

Chief executive Omar Berrada, director of football Jason Wilcox and co-owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe are meeting in the principality for what is officially billed as a regular strategic review. In reality, the agenda has a single, brutal headline: whether Carrick survives the week.

The expectation inside the club is that he will not. Berrada and Wilcox are understood to be ready to recommend a change, with United marooned in 18th place in the Premier League after winning just one of their first 10 games and none since August. This is their lowest position at this stage of a top-flight campaign since 1986-87, when they sat 20th.

Carrick was pictured arriving at the Carrington training base on Wednesday morning, going about his routine while the walls close in elsewhere.

Pochettino back in United’s sights

As Carrick waits, United have moved decisively in the background. Discussions are under way with Pochettino about a return to the Premier League, the fourth time the club have sounded him out about the job.

United first approached the former Argentina defender in 2018 after sacking Jose Mourinho, then again in 2022 before appointing Erik ten Hag, and once more when the Dutchman was dismissed in 2024. Each time, circumstances or timing pushed Pochettino to the periphery. This time, the pressure of the league table is dragging him back to the centre of the conversation.

The 54-year-old renewed his contract with the USA in August and is currently preparing for a two-legged Concacaf Nations League quarter-final against Haiti over the next week. Any move would have to cut across that schedule and trigger a significant financial outlay: Pochettino’s deal includes a $10m (£7.5m) release clause.

United know exactly what they would be buying. Pochettino’s Premier League story began at Southampton in January 2013, where he transformed the south-coast club into one of the division’s most aggressive, tactically modern sides. Tottenham came next in 2014: five years, a Champions League final, and a team that regularly harassed the summit of the table even without the financial firepower of their rivals.

His work with Paris St-Germain from January 2021 to July 2022 brought the familiar demands of a superstar dressing room, before he returned to England for the 2023-24 season in charge of Chelsea, trying to steady another turbulent project.

From World Cup stage to Old Trafford shortlist

Pochettino stepped into international football in September 2024 with the USA, guiding the co-hosts to the last 16 of the 2026 World Cup. That run reinforced his reputation as a coach who can build structure and identity quickly, even under the glare of a major tournament.

Now his name sits at the top of Manchester United’s shortlist again, this time with a relegation fight looming behind it.

The Monaco meeting will decide Carrick’s fate and, by extension, how aggressively United push to prise Pochettino from his current post. The club’s hierarchy has flown out to talk strategy; the league table has turned that strategy session into a crisis council.

United once chased Pochettino as a luxury option. Today, with the club staring up from the bottom reaches of the table, he looks far more like a necessity.