Manchester United's Managerial Search: Wilcox's Preferred Successor
Jason Wilcox has quietly settled on his preferred successor to Michael Carrick at Manchester United – and two other strong candidates have already been pushed to the side.
Carrick’s position looks increasingly fragile. United have lost five of their first 11 games in all competitions, but it was the 4-1 collapse away to Como on Wednesday that ripped the veneer off the project. Outplayed by Champions League debutants, humiliated on the scoreboard, and then torn apart in the post-match fallout, United looked every inch a club without a clear direction.
Bruno Fernandes made sure the world knew it. The captain broke ranks after the final whistle, publicly questioning Carrick’s tactics. The comments detonated across the punditry landscape. Wayne Rooney led the backlash, labelling Fernandes and Lisandro Martinez – who had taken aim at technical director Jason Wilcox a week earlier – as “selfish babies”.
The dressing room noise has only amplified the pressure. There were whispers Carrick might not even make it to the weekend, but he will be in the dugout for Sunday’s clash with Bournemouth and is scheduled to face the media on Friday afternoon.
Wilcox backs Carrick… for now
According to The Athletic, Wilcox is still, at this moment, backing Carrick. That backing, though, comes with a clear caveat. Co-owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe retains the power to overrule him and could move to sack the former midfielder, with the billionaire leaning on data-driven tools – including AI – to help shape the search for the next manager.
Wilcox, aware of how quickly the ground can shift at Old Trafford, has already started preparing for the worst. He has drawn up his own shortlist, and talkSPORT’s chief football correspondent Alex Crook reports that the technical director is now “leaning towards Eddie Howe” as his preferred choice.
This is not a name plucked from nowhere. Howe has hovered around United’s thinking before. When Erik ten Hag’s future first came under serious scrutiny, former sporting director Dan Ashworth had pushed for Howe, then at Newcastle, to be the man to take over. In the end, Wilcox opted for Ruben Amorim at that stage of the club’s planning, but Howe never drifted far from the conversation.
Howe at the head of the queue
Inside the current power structure, there is not total agreement. Director of recruitment Christopher Vivell is understood to be championing Julian Nagelsmann. Wilcox, though, sees Howe as the better fit for this version of United, favouring his extensive Premier League experience. In the corridors that matter – Ratcliffe’s office and the Glazer family’s boardroom – Wilcox’s voice is likely to carry more weight than Vivell’s.
Howe is available after leaving Newcastle in the summer. Reports have suggested he wanted a longer break from the touchline, time to reset after an intense spell on Tyneside. Yet the sense within the game is clear: if Manchester United call, that sabbatical suddenly looks negotiable. The feeling is he would be interested if the vacancy formally opens.
Two contenders ruled out
Wilcox has not limited his search to Howe and Nagelsmann. Unai Emery and Fabian Hürzeler both fit the profile he is working from: progressive coaches, tactically sharp, strong organisers. On paper, they tick the boxes.
Reality, though, has stripped them from the live shortlist. Emery would be prohibitively expensive to prise away from Aston Villa, where he has built a side capable of challenging the established order and holds a powerful position within the club. Hürzeler, meanwhile, is content at Brighton and, at this stage, is not prepared to walk away for United.
So the picture sharpens. Carrick clings on ahead of Bournemouth, the hierarchy publicly supportive but privately planning. Howe waits on the outside, a free agent with Premier League scars and credentials, as Ratcliffe’s data models and Wilcox’s football instincts circle the same central question:
How long can Manchester United afford to hesitate?






