logo

Manchester City: Time for Reflection Amid Uncertainty

Enzo Maresca finally has something he has barely been granted since walking into Pep Guardiola’s old office: time.

The international break arrives as Manchester City’s season judders for the first time under their new manager. Seven straight league wins had painted a familiar picture – City out in front, the rest scrambling for answers. Three defeats later, they trail Arsenal by six points and suddenly the questions are aimed at them.

And they are not just about tactics or team selection. Not this season.

A title defence under a cloud

The backdrop is impossible to ignore. In September, City were found guilty of breaking the Premier League’s financial rules. The club have appealed and life, on the surface, has gone on. Matches, press conferences, training sessions – the usual rhythms.

Underneath, it is different.

Renowned sports psychologist Dr Paul McCarthy, who has spent 25 years working with elite clubs in England, Scotland, Germany and France, describes what happens when uncertainty seeps into a dressing room.

“Players are like everyone else – they talk about what is going on in their own lives and things that are topical, especially about uncertain events,” he tells BBC Sport. Those conversations, the stories and rumours, can chip away at something vital.

Over time, he says, enough setbacks can erode “collective efficacy” – a squad’s shared belief in its ability to do what it needs to do to win. For a group built on relentless success, three straight league defeats feel heavier than the numbers alone suggest.

Asked if the unresolved appeal could be affecting focus, McCarthy is blunt: “Yeah, that would be a very reasonable human response.

“When people are uncertain about their future, that uncertainty leads to a lack of perceived control, so uncertainty is often more stressful than bad news and the research shows that.”

Players can still train, still play, still prepare. But the biggest question of their season sits beyond their reach. “It’s outside of their responsibility,” McCarthy notes. That loss of control lingers.

From flawless to fragile

On the pitch, the shift has been stark.

City opened the campaign with seven wins from seven, sitting comfortably at the top without conceding a single goal from an individual error. They looked, again, like the side everyone else had to catch.

They now sit third, behind Arsenal and Brighton, and the cracks are suddenly obvious. Since the last international break – when the guilty verdict was announced – the pattern has twisted.

Maresca’s side returned with a statement win at Anfield, beating 10-man Liverpool, then edged past Ipswich at Etihad Stadium. The machine still seemed intact.

Then came Aston Villa. Then Brighton. Then Nottingham Forest. Three defeats, three different warning signs, one common theme: vulnerability.

In those three games alone, four individual mistakes led directly to goals. City have conceded 13 times in their first 10 league fixtures – their worst defensive record at this stage since 2008-09, when they had shipped 16. For a club that has built its modern era on control, that number stings.

This is not just about bad luck. It is about structure, personnel, and a bold tactical gamble that is still bedding in.

Maresca’s 3-1-6 gamble

Maresca has never hidden his ideas. While on Chelsea’s staff, he laid out his thinking in a video for NBC Sports: counters morphing into a 3-2-2-3, then into a 3-1-6 as one midfielder steps higher. Six attackers pinning back a back five, overloading the last line.

Against Inter Milan, he used that 3-1-6 shape to outnumber their defence. This season at City, that aggressive structure has become the default, not a situational weapon.

The trade-off is clear. One holding midfielder instead of two. One extra attacking midfielder in exchange for a little less insurance in front of the back line.

With a squad packed with technical quality, the temptation is obvious. Push the game onto opponents. Squeeze them in. Dictate.

But systems only sing when the players in key roles fit the demands. Right now, the biggest question mark sits in the heart of midfield.

The Anderson experiment

Elliot Anderson is at the centre of it all.

By nature, he is a roaming midfielder – energetic, physical, happy to press high and wide, to join attacks and disrupt opponents. At Nottingham Forest, he thrived doing exactly that: defending aggressively, hunting the ball, springing forward.

This season, Maresca and his staff are asking him to become something else. With Rodri gone in the summer, Anderson is being reshaped into more of a sitting midfielder, the anchor in that 3-1-6.

It is a huge ask. It took Rodri time to master that role when he first arrived. Reading danger, holding position, resisting the urge to chase – those habits do not change overnight.

Anderson has largely impressed, but he is still playing to type. He steps out to press, to track runners, to win the ball back. Smart opponents have spotted it. They drag him away from the centre, then find passes straight through the middle he has just vacated.

The issue is not the shape on a whiteboard. It is what happens when City lose the ball.

After the defeat to Forest, Maresca cut straight to it: “You concede transitions when you lose the ball, and when you don’t win duels.” In a 3-1-6, those moments are brutal. Lose it high, lose a duel in the first line, and the lone holding midfielder stands exposed.

When that midfielder is still learning the role, the risk multiplies.

Building from the back without their best builders

Behind Anderson, the picture is no calmer.

Gianluigi Donnarumma remains a giant presence in goal, but he is not known for his passing. He is no playmaking goalkeeper. The defenders in front of him can use the ball, but this season they have cracked under pressure, gifting chances while trying to play out from the back.

Under Guardiola, City solved similar problems by shifting responsibility. Midfielders dropped deep, took the ball off defenders, and carried the team through the first phase. Rodri did it. Bernardo Silva did it even more. He would drop almost onto the toes of his centre-backs, glide past pressure, and deliver City into midfield.

Both are gone. The absence is glaring.

As talented as Anderson is, he is not yet the man who can single-handedly tidy up the build-up, dictate tempo, and calm nerves the way Bernardo did. Without that kind of outlet, Donnarumma and the back line face more pressure, more often, with fewer easy solutions.

There is, perhaps, one internal answer. Ayyoub Bouaddi has shown he can operate under extreme pressure, particularly against Brazil’s press at the World Cup. He might be the player Maresca turns to when he wants someone to drop deep, take the ball in tight spaces and stitch the whole thing together.

A reset, or the start of a slide?

So the break comes at a delicate moment.

The psychology of uncertainty. The tactical risk of a permanent 3-1-6. A converted holding midfielder still learning his angles. A goalkeeper and defence asked to build from the back without their best midfield escape routes.

Maresca now has a fortnight to work without the noise of back-to-back fixtures. To drill Anderson’s positioning. To decide how much he can persist with this level of attacking commitment. To weigh up whether Bouaddi becomes a deeper fulcrum.

City have been here before in a different guise: questions swirling, doubts forming, rivals sensing opportunity. The difference this time is that the storm is not only on the pitch.

The appeal verdict will land when it lands. Maresca cannot control that. What he can control is what City look like when it does – a team shaken by uncertainty, or one that has used this break to rebuild its belief, piece by piece, from back to front.