Could Manchester City’s FFP Controversy Reignite Super League Debate? Danny Mills Cites LIV Golf as a Warning
Will Man City's Financial Fair Play Issues Spark Super League Discussions?
The ongoing Financial Fair Play (FFP) case involving Manchester City has brought spending rules back into focus. This raises the question of whether talks about a European Super League might resurface. Former City defender Danny Mills shared his perspective with GOAL, explaining why such a breakaway competition remains unlikely. He used the example of the LIV Golf venture as a cautionary tale for football clubs and governing bodies tempted to go their own way.
The Fallout from the 2021 Super League Attempt
In early 2021, a group of 12 top clubs planned to create a new tournament, aiming for 20 teams eventually. The English 'Big Six'—including City, Liverpool, Manchester United, Chelsea, Arsenal, and Tottenham—were part of this. The proposal met fierce opposition from fans and was abandoned quickly. Despite that, the idea hasn’t completely vanished. Clubs like Real Madrid and Juventus have kept some support alive.
One major hurdle for a Super League is that players involved wouldn’t be eligible for international matches organized by UEFA or FIFA. This restricts transfers and affects player motivation. Yet, such a league would allow clubs with wealthy owners to bypass FFP and other rules, enabling unrestricted spending. Manchester City currently faces serious charges related to FFP violations, which could result in severe penalties.
Why Players Would Resist a European Super League
Mills explained why a breakaway competition wouldn't attract players despite financial incentives. Speaking with GOAL, he said, “To play international football, FIFA have to approve your competition. Without that, no player can represent their country in major tournaments.”He added that players cherish the prestige of winning international trophies more than club titles alone. Success on the world stage brings lasting recognition and honors, like knighthoods, unlike club achievements, which may be forgotten over time. Mills pointed out that efforts in other countries, like Saudi Arabia and China, to establish separate leagues have failed, showing that top players will always want international competition.
LIV Golf Shows Independent Leagues Can Struggle
The LIV Golf series tried attracting top golfers with big contracts and a fresh format but is now facing bankruptcy. This highlights how new competitions face major challenges.
Mills compared LIV Golf to the Super League, noting, “They found a short-term fix but it fell apart because the sport wasn’t entertaining. Fans want competition where winning and losing matter.”
He emphasized the importance of relegation and promotion systems that keep leagues exciting. Without stakes, matches lose intensity and viewers lose interest. Expanding playoffs in the English Championship, for example, has made the season more competitive. Mills warned that a closed Super League could become dull if teams feel they have nothing to play for mid-season.
What Lies Ahead for Manchester City?
Manchester City is still awaiting the outcome of its FFP appeals. The Premier League faces uncertainty about potential sanctions including points deductions, transfer bans, or even expulsion from the league. This raises questions about the validity of current competitions and trophies if harsh penalties are imposed on the club.
- Next Match: Manchester City vs Ipswich Town
- Competition: Premier League
- Date & Time: 17 October 2026, 17:00






