Liverpool Should Have Been Awarded Penalty, Says Premier League Panel
The Premier League’s own review panel has delivered its verdict – and it makes grim reading for Liverpool.
Days after a narrow 1-0 defeat to Arsenal, the Key Match Incidents (KMI) Panel has ruled that Liverpool should have been awarded a penalty for a shirt pull on Alexander Isak, and that VAR ought to have stepped in.
Panel overturns on-field call
The flashpoint came with Liverpool trailing to Kai Havertz’s 16th-minute strike, the only goal of the game. Isak moved to attack a cross, only to be checked by Jurrien Timber, who appeared to grab his shirt as the striker went to meet the ball.
Referee and VAR both waved play on. No penalty, no review on the monitor, game continues.
The panel has now gone firmly against that combined decision. By a margin of 4–1, it concluded that the incident met the threshold for a holding offence and should have resulted in a Liverpool spot-kick.
On top of that, a 3–2 majority felt VAR should have intervened and recommended an on-field review. The minority view rested on “subjectivity in assessing impact” – essentially arguing that the officials were entitled to judge the contact as not clearly affecting Isak’s ability to play the ball.
One panellist, who did not consider it a penalty, described the contact as “short-lived holding” that lacked “clear impact on the ability of Isak to progress”. They were outvoted.
Laws, letters and a missed threshold
The Premier League also restated the criteria referees are expected to use when judging holding offences: whether a player focuses solely on an opponent rather than the ball, whether there is any attempt to play or challenge for the ball, if both arms are used, and whether the holding is sustained or impactful on the opponent or their clothing.
In this case, the KMI Panel decided Timber’s challenge ticked enough of those boxes to cross the line. In their view, it should have been a penalty both on the field and via VAR.
For Liverpool, that ruling changes nothing in the table. But it sharpens the sense of injustice.
Iraola: “Everyone sees the shirt”
Andoni Iraola did not need a panel to tell him what he thought he had seen in real time.
“I think the Isak one is a clear penalty,” the Liverpool manager said after the match. “He's going to head the ball in front of the goal, and they grab him where everyone sees the shirt.
“You don't need a lot, just to avoid Alex, because the ball just goes in front of him, and I don't see the reason why, probably because he doesn't dive or he doesn't go to the floor. It shouldn't be a reason not to concede a penalty.”
There was no appetite from Iraola to wage a public war with PGMOL, though. He sounded resigned to the process and its limitations.
“It's not going to change anything if we talk to the PGMOL or not. I think we have to wait now, I think it's 10 days or 12 days until they give the resolution.
“It's going to be what it is and that's it, accept it and let's go for the next one, no? It's not going to change.”
Pundits united – on opposite sides of the divide
The incident did something rare: it put a Liverpool legend and an Arsenal legend on the same side of the argument.
Jamie Carragher, on Sky Sports duty, could not hide his disbelief.
"One of the best goalscorers in the league is pulled back seven yards out and it stops him heading the ball - why does he need to make a meal of it? VAR, do your job," he said.
Ian Wright, fiercely partisan in most Arsenal debates, did not try to defend the decision either.
“It's obvious he's pulled his shirt. Why does he need to dive? He shouldn't have to make more of it,” Wright said. “VAR is wrong in this instance. Of course it's my team and I'm happy we've won it. But if they gave that penalty, I wouldn't sit here and say: 'I can't believe they gave that'.”
When rivals with that pedigree agree, the noise around an incident tends to grow louder.
Another mark against VAR
This is not the first time a post-match review has contradicted both referee and VAR this season, and it will not be the last. Each time it happens, confidence in the technology and those operating it takes another hit.
For Arsenal, Havertz’s early goal still stands as the difference. For Liverpool, the record shows a 1-0 defeat and no penalty awarded.
The panel’s ruling only leaves one lingering question: in a title race and European chase decided by fine margins, how many of these “should have been” moments can a season absorb?






