Liverpool Denied Penalty Against Arsenal: VAR Under Scrutiny
Liverpool were denied a penalty they should have had against Arsenal at Anfield, according to the Premier League’s Key Match Incidents Panel – and VAR has been placed firmly back under the microscope.
Panel says Liverpool should have had spot-kick
The flashpoint came in the 21st minute on 1 November. Bradley Barcola whipped in a cross, Alexander Isak darted across the near post and stretched to meet it. He missed the ball by inches.
Replays showed why.
Jurrien Timber had a fistful of Isak’s shirt, clearly tugging him back as the Liverpool forward attacked the delivery. Referee Andy Madley waved play on. VAR Stuart Attwell checked the incident and allowed the game to continue.
The KMI Panel has now ruled that decision wrong on two fronts.
By a 4–1 majority, the panel agreed a penalty should have been awarded on the field. On top of that, it voted 3–2 that VAR should have stepped in and sent Madley to the pitchside monitor, branding the non-intervention a “clear and obvious error”.
At the time, Arsenal were 1-0 up thanks to Kai Havertz’s strike. That goal settled the contest. The panel’s verdict will only sharpen the sense of what might have been for Liverpool in a tight, single-goal defeat.
Two panellists pushed back, stressing the “subjectivity in assessing impact” – essentially, how much Timber’s shirt pull actually prevented Isak from making contact with the ball. The majority, though, felt the images left little room for doubt.
One point of agreement did emerge: Timber’s foul did not reach the threshold for a red card for denying an obvious goalscoring opportunity. On that, the panel was unanimous.
Isak, crucially, stayed on his feet.
Iraola’s frustration vindicated
In the immediate aftermath, Liverpool manager Andoni Iraola did not hide his anger when he spoke to BBC Match of the Day.
“There is a clear grab of the shirt,” he said. “Alex was just in front of him. He was going to head in front of the goal, but couldn't because he grabbed the shirt.
“If he goes to the floor, they call the penalty, 100%. It should be like this, but it is what it is.
“Next time, the managers should tell Alex to go to the floor, otherwise they won't call it.
“The answer is you have to dive. If you don't dive they won't call it.”
Those comments cut to the heart of a long-running grievance in the modern game: honesty versus reward. Stay upright and risk being ignored, or go down and force the referee’s hand. The panel’s ruling will only fuel the debate Iraola tapped into so bluntly.
Second VAR mistake in Ipswich–Hull
The Arsenal–Liverpool controversy was not the only error flagged from that round of fixtures.
The KMI Panel also found VAR at fault in Ipswich’s 2-2 draw with Hull City on 31 October.
With the score 0-0, Ipswich defender Dara O’Shea was held back at a corner by Nobel Mendy. Referee Peter Bankes missed the offence. VAR Neil Davies did not intervene.
The panel concluded Ipswich should have been awarded a penalty. Instead, play continued. Ipswich went on to take the lead soon after, but Hull fought back and the match finished level.
Two games, two missed penalties, two VAR teams left answering awkward questions. For a system designed to clean up the game’s biggest calls, the scrutiny is only getting sharper.






