logo

Liverpool's Disciplinary Struggles in a Strange Season

Liverpool are topping a Premier League table nobody wants to lead.

With 128 fouls conceded so far, more than any other side in the division according to The Independent, Andoni Iraola’s team are discovering an awkward edge to their high‑energy football. At the same time, they sit near the bottom of the scale for fouls won, with only three teams earning fewer than their 88.

High intensity, low reward.

It fits a campaign their manager openly calls “strange”.

Honest to a fault?

Liverpool arrive at Selhurst Park on Sunday on the back of two bruising defeats, beaten by Arsenal in the league and Fenerbahce in Europe. Both games left a sour aftertaste. Against Arsenal, they were denied a penalty despite Alexander Isak having his shirt clearly tugged in the box, a moment that fed directly into the narrative raised at Iraola’s press conference.

He insists his players do not go looking for soft decisions. They do not roll, squeal or surround referees. And that, he suggested, might be costing them.

“We are quite an honest group, sometimes too honest,” Iraola said. “Even the other day after the game, the referee congratulated us… I'm not sure if I like that or not!

“Our behaviour was very good. I think it has to be genuine; you cannot fake things; it has to be genuine complaints. We are willing, we want to press, we want to be intense – but the balance is that there's a big difference.”

That balance is the crux of Liverpool’s season. They want to hunt the ball, drive games and suffocate opponents, yet the numbers show a side giving away more free-kicks than anyone else while rarely drawing whistles in their favour. For a team that lives off rhythm and territory, that constant stop-start hurts.

Two faces of Liverpool

The league table tells one story, the scorelines another.

Liverpool sit fifth in the Premier League, nine points behind leaders Arsenal. Defensively, the record looks solid: just nine goals conceded in nine league matches. It suggests structure, control, a team that knows how to manage 90 minutes.

Then you glance at Europe.

In the Champions League, Liverpool have already shipped 10 goals in only four matches, even as they score freely at the other end. The contrast is stark enough for Iraola to label the campaign “a strange season”.

“In the Champions League, we are scoring a lot and conceding a lot. In the Premier League, we are scoring less and conceding less. We obviously want to score more, concede less!” he said.

For him, the issue lies in how they manage phases of play. Against Fenerbahce, Liverpool had the ball, the territory, the shape. What they lacked was chaos in the right areas.

“It's a matter of controlling the games. Sometimes against Fenerbahce, we're controlling too much, having good positions and arriving but sometimes we have to throw numbers in the box. It will take away more control, yes, but it gives us more threat. Especially against Arsenal… the way we attack the box has to be better.”

There is the dilemma laid bare: keep control and risk becoming predictable, or flood the area, lose a little order and become dangerous again.

Palace away and the need for a response

A week ago, Liverpool were riding a positive run. Confidence high, mood light, everything moving in the right direction. Two defeats later, the tone has shifted.

“A week ago, we were on a run and in a good place and in a better mood,” Iraola admitted. “Now it changes and it has to be like this. We have to react after two defeats: we need the win against Palace away.”

Selhurst Park is no place to drift through a game. Palace will test Liverpool’s discipline, their physicality and that uneasy relationship with referees’ whistles. If the foul count spikes again and the Reds fail to draw decisions in the final third, the frustration will only deepen.

Team news offers another small concern. Ryan Gravenberch is “touch and go” for the trip as he continues to manage heel pain, leaving Iraola with a decision in midfield at a time when control and aggression in that area are under the microscope.

Liverpool travel to south London as the Premier League’s most penalised side, a team praised by officials for their honesty but punished by the numbers. How long can they keep walking that line before something has to give – the approach, the discipline, or their place in the chasing pack?