logo

Juventus Denied Late Victory by Controversial Handball Call in Florence

The anger in black and white was impossible to miss. In a chaotic, breathless 2-2 draw at Fiorentina, Juventus walked off the Artemio Franchi pitch convinced that a single decision had stripped them of two precious points and, perhaps, a slice of momentum in their Serie A climb.

A wild night in Florence

The game itself swung like a pendulum.

Fiorentina struck first through Mateo Pellegrino, seizing on early uncertainty and igniting the home crowd. Juventus hit back through Nick Woltemade, who dragged the visitors level and briefly calmed the noise.

The pattern repeated. Alieu Njie restored Fiorentina’s lead, only for Gleison Bremer to respond, imposing himself in the box and hauling Juventus back into the contest again. Twice behind, twice level. The Bianconeri refused to fold, but they never quite took control.

And so it rolled into the closing stages, tense, open, and desperate. One moment would define it.

The incident that lit the fuse

With the scores locked at 2-2 in the final minutes, Juventus pushed for a winner. Then came the flashpoint.

A cross, a scramble, a deflection. The ball struck Joao Mario inside the Fiorentina penalty area. On the arm.

The referee waved play on. No whistle, no pause. VAR stayed silent.

Juventus players protested, arms raised, but the game carried on. When the final whistle arrived, their frustration boiled over into something sharper: a sense of injustice.

Across Italy, the debate erupted almost instantly.

VAR under fire

Italian media did not sit on the fence.

La Gazzetta dello Sport, Tuttosport, and Corriere dello Sport all reached the same conclusion: it should have been a penalty to Juventus. The images, replayed from every angle, only hardened that view.

Former referee and DAZN analyst Luca Marelli dissected the episode with forensic detail. He dismissed the idea that the deflection made the contact acceptable.

“The point of contact is below the elbow, more on the arm than in the armpit,” Marelli told DAZN. The ball did change direction unexpectedly, he noted, but Joao Mario’s arm was nowhere near a natural position.

At the moment of impact, Marelli highlighted, the Fiorentina player’s arm sat at an unnatural 90-degree angle, away from his body. Kolo Muani had missed the initial header, the ball had flicked off a boot, yet the arm remained extended and inviting trouble.

“There is no doubt the Fiorentina player touched the ball with his arm, and he should have been punished,” Marelli said. Calling it “unexpected,” he argued, was only one possible interpretation, not a justification for inaction. For him, VAR had a clear duty: send the referee to the monitor and let him award the penalty.

That didn’t happen. Juventus were left with fury instead of a spot-kick.

Two points lost, not one gained

On the table, the damage is clear enough. Juventus sit seventh, with 18 points from their first 11 league matches. In a season where the margins near the top already look tight, nights like this sting.

The character is there. Coming from behind twice away from home is no small thing, especially in Florence, where the atmosphere rarely gives visiting sides any comfort. Yet resilience without reward can quickly feel hollow.

For Massimiliano Allegri’s men, this will go down as two points dropped, not one earned. The chance to close the gap on the teams above them slipped away in a moment of controversy and a silent VAR booth.

Fiorentina, by contrast, escaped. They stared at a late collapse, survived the penalty scare, and clung to a point that keeps them 15th on nine points. For a side trying to steady itself, that matters.

Pressure rising in Turin

The wider picture is unforgiving. Juventus cannot afford to linger in mid-table if they are serious about rescuing their domestic campaign. Draws, however dramatic, will not be enough.

They now face an uphill push through the fixtures ahead, carrying both the encouragement of their fightback and the bitterness of the decision that went against them. The emotional swing is sharp: from defiance to disbelief in a handful of seconds.

What they do with that anger will shape the weeks to come. Turn it into an edge, and this night in Florence becomes a rallying point. Let it fester, and it may be remembered as the moment their season slipped just that little bit further out of reach.