logo

Julian Nagelsmann's Departure from Bayern: Insider Critiques Club's Culture

The Julian Nagelsmann story at Bayern Munich did not end with a press release in March 2023. It still lingers, and for at least one man who worked inside the club, it still stings.

Dr Maximilian Pelka, Bayern’s team psychologist from 2021 to 2023, has criticised the way the German champions handled Nagelsmann’s dismissal, describing a decision that, in his eyes, said as much about the club’s culture as it did about the coach.

A Sacking on the Slopes

Nagelsmann was relieved of his duties during an international break in March 2023, while on a short skiing holiday. The trip had been approved by the club. It later became a key talking point in the narrative of his departure.

Club patriarch Uli Hoeneß would go on to say that this spontaneous break, taken just after a damaging Bundesliga defeat to Bayer 04 Leverkusen, played a decisive role in Bayern’s decision to act. The image stuck: the coach under pressure, the title race in the balance, and Nagelsmann on the mountain instead of at Säbener Straße.

Inside the club, that framing never sat well with everyone.

“Everyone Always Wants More, More, More”

Speaking to kicker, Pelka painted a very different picture of the situation Bayern were actually in when they pulled the trigger.

“Perhaps we need to explain again what situation the club was in at the time,” he said. Bayern were not in freefall. They were in the quarter-finals of the DFB Cup. They had just knocked PSG – with Lionel Messi, Neymar and Kylian Mbappé – out of the Champions League. The problem lay in the Bundesliga table: Bayern sat second, behind Borussia Dortmund.

That was enough to crank up the pressure in Munich. As Pelka put it, the demands around the club are relentless: “Everyone always wants more, more, more.”

A 2-1 defeat away to Leverkusen lit the fuse. On the Monday after that loss, Nagelsmann reported to his office at Säbener Straße and went about his work as usual. Only once the majority of his squad had departed for international duty did he step away and take his short break.

A Holiday Turned into a Verdict

For Pelka, the subsequent criticism of that decision – and the implication that Nagelsmann had not handled the crisis correctly – was deeply unfair.

“He is an adult. I don't need to recommend anything to him,” Pelka said. International breaks, he argued, give coaches a rare opportunity to “step off the treadmill for a while.” To turn that into evidence of negligence did not reflect the reality of high-pressure coaching life.

Pelka acknowledged that the sporting situation was tense. Bayern, by their standards, were wobbling. But he insisted Nagelsmann’s response was entirely reasonable: “Taking three or four days away from the madness to clear his head. With all the national team players away anyway, that was exactly the right thing to do.”

In his view, the Bayern coach was not escaping the pressure; he was preparing to face it.

“Of course everyone wants to see you keep working during a difficult period,” Pelka said. Then he posed the central question: “But does that make sense in the end? Or does it make more sense to recharge so you can be fully there again over the following weeks and months?” As far as he knew, he added, the trip “had also been agreed.”

The implication is sharp. A break that had been signed off internally later became part of the public justification for a sacking. For someone whose job was to protect mental resilience within the squad and staff, that was a bitter twist.

Bayern’s Standards, Bayern’s Fallout

At Bayern, context rarely softens judgment. Being second in the league, even with a Champions League quarter-final ahead and PSG already dispatched, can be enough to bring a project to a halt. The Leverkusen defeat, the sight of Dortmund above them, the sense that the season might slip – all of it fed into a decision that came “out of the blue” to many on the inside.

Nagelsmann paid the price. His skiing holiday, taken in what he believed was a logical window to breathe and reset, became part of the case against him. For Pelka, that episode exposes a wider truth about the environment: expectation at Bayern does not pause, not even for a few days in the mountains.

After Munich: A New Peak, Then a Fall

Nagelsmann did not stay on the market for long. In September 2023, he took over as Germany coach at the DFB, stepping into the national job many had long predicted for him.

That chapter, too, ended abruptly. He remained in charge for almost three years before a disappointing performance at the 2026 World Cup brought his tenure to an early close. The DFB turned to Jürgen Klopp as his successor, a heavyweight appointment that instantly reset the mood around the national team.

Nagelsmann, once the brightest young coach in German football, now finds himself without a club. His Bayern spell, and the manner of its end, still casts a shadow. The question is no longer why he went skiing, or whether he should have stayed in his office during an international break.

The real question is who will trust him next to lead a project under the kind of pressure that, in Munich at least, never truly allows a coach to step off the treadmill.