Gary Neville criticizes Manchester United's handling of Carrick
Manchester United’s handling of Michael Carrick’s departure has drawn a ferocious rebuke from one of their own. Gary Neville, never shy of a verdict on his former club, has branded the treatment of the outgoing manager “disgusting” and a damning reflection of the current regime.
The former United captain believes the club effectively allowed Carrick to resign in public, then dithered while plotting his replacement from afar.
Neville said he felt the writing was already on the wall after the Bournemouth game, when Carrick walked the pitch and waved to the supporters. “I think after the Bournemouth game I said at the time that Manchester United effectively watched Michael Carrick resign on the pitch at the end of the game with that lap around, that wave goodbye. I think he was expecting it to come at that point and they were indecisive.”
The delay, in Neville’s eyes, told its own story. United were expected to sack Carrick on Monday. The decision did not arrive until Thursday, by which time the club had already moved to appoint Mauricio Pochettino as his successor.
“They obviously felt that they might be able to get to the international break and there could be some sort of pick-up in results, but it’s been a difficult two weeks. Indecision, lack of authority, just basically really poor leadership,” Neville said.
Then came the detail that truly enraged him. As Carrick took training in Manchester, club executives and owners were in Monaco, while simultaneously engaging with the US Soccer Federation over Pochettino.
“In the last 24-48 hours it’s been spectacularly bad to be in Monaco as an executive and an owner whilst your manager, who’s a club legend, is taking training on the pitch and simultaneously approaching the US Soccer Federation to approach Mauricio Pochettino,” Neville said. “It’s just quite simply disgusting. That falls well below the standard of what you would expect in any other business, in any other industry. It would be constructive dismissal and you’d be getting sued.”
He did not stop there. The optics, he argued, cut straight to the heart of United’s leadership crisis.
“The optics of being in Monaco whilst the team, the staff, the people who are running the club on a day-to-day basis are in Manchester, it’s just not good and it reflects badly on the leadership. I don’t think anybody comes out of this well at all.”
While Neville fired shots at the boardroom, Carrick chose a very different tone. His departure statement, released on social media, read like a love letter to a club he insists he will never stop supporting.
“I’ve had the immense privilege of leading Manchester United, the football club that I love. There are very few who get to live that and feel it, and for that I’m incredibly grateful,” he wrote.
“With that comes huge responsibility, and to be at Manchester United, you need to understand exactly what that means. It’s different to anywhere else.
“Ultimately, you need to push to be the best, but there is a culture, there are values and there are behaviours that you have to live by and respect, which have been built over a long period of time.
“It’s a football club that is unique, with substance and history that cannot be ignored. This is what inspired me every single day.”
Carrick reserved special praise for the supporters, describing them as “a special, rare breed”.
“We’ve had some great times this year and moments we’ll all remember. The best thing about being in my position was seeing so many of you lose yourselves in the emotion of those moments, leaving the stadium desperate to come back again next time.
“I just wanted to give you something back. That love never dies.
“I know we’ve not had the results lately, but you’ve shown me nothing but love and support in times when the easiest thing, and what most end up doing, would be to turn the other way.
“That means more than a win or two. That’s what makes you who you are.
“That’s why I fell in love with this club all those years ago.”
He thanked his coaching staff for their “loyalty, hard work and support”, and paid tribute to the often-unseen workers behind the scenes. “So much of your work goes unseen, but it never goes unappreciated,” he said.
Carrick also addressed his players directly. “To the players, thank you for your efforts and the moments we’ve shared. I wish you all the very best for what’s ahead.”
His closing words underlined just how deep the bond runs. “I want nothing but success for Manchester United. This club has been such a big part of my life and that will never change. I’ll always be proud to have played my part and I’ll always want the very best for it.
“I’ll be right there with you from now on, watching from the sidelines, cheering the lads on.”
While United wrestle with the fallout, the wider game moves on. Mauricio Pochettino steps into the Old Trafford spotlight, tasked with bringing order to a club Neville accuses of “really poor leadership”.
Elsewhere, Crystal Palace have acted decisively, dismissing Pierre Sage with Thomas Frank emerging as the favourite to take over. On the international front, Wales face Norway, while Portugal meet Denmark in their first outing since Cristiano Ronaldo announced his retirement from international football.
In the WSL, Chelsea host Manchester City in the standout fixture of a four-game slate.
The calendar is full, the fixtures keep coming, the noise never stops. Yet at Old Trafford, one question lingers above it all: how long can a club of such history live with leadership that its own icons describe as “disgusting”?






