Everton's Challenge at Arsenal: Injury Woes and Tactical Gambles
Everton head to North London on Saturday carrying scars, doubts and a miserable record at the Emirates Stadium – but also the faint freedom that comes when nobody really expects anything from you.
Last weekend’s home defeat to Chelsea stripped away what little optimism there was around Goodison. Any remaining belief took another hit when David Moyes sat down in front of the cameras this week and hinted that several squad players are carrying knocks, refusing to say who. It sounded less like mind games and more like a manager bracing himself for another long afternoon.
Across the divide, Arsenal look ominous. Second in the table, beaten only by leaders Manchester City, and with a defence that has coughed up just five goals – joint-best in the league. They have not just been efficient; at times they’ve been suffocating, closing games down with the authority of a side that expects to be in the title conversation deep into spring.
Injury puzzles and selection gambles
Moyes’ problems start at the back. Jarrad Branthwaite and Vitaliy Mykolenko both scraped through late fitness tests to feature against Chelsea. They survived, but that does not automatically make them safe bets for another high-intensity 90 minutes. Everton’s medical team will have spent the week walking a tightrope between necessity and risk.
Summer signing Christian Nørgaard is the other headache. Moyes insisted before Chelsea that the midfielder was ready. The pitch told a different story. Nørgaard looked off the pace, off the rhythm, and the manager admitted as much in his pre-Arsenal press conference, revealing he had even considered starting him before thinking better of it. It was a rare public nod to a selection misjudgment from a coach who usually keeps those thoughts in-house.
Arsenal have issues of their own. Mikel Arteta, once recruited to Everton by Moyes and now the figurehead of Arsenal’s resurgence, will be without Bukayo Saka, William Saliba and Christos Tzolis. That’s a significant chunk of their usual spine and spark removed in one hit. Piero Hincapie, though, could be available and may offer Arteta some welcome flexibility in his defensive setup.
Everton’s likely approach
On paper, Everton are expected to stick with the 4-1-4-1 that has become their default under Moyes. In reality, it often morphs into something closer to a deep 4-5-1, with long spells without the ball and a heavy reliance on structure, concentration and Jordan Pickford’s reflexes.
Pickford will start in goal. In front of him, if they’re passed fit again, Mykolenko and Branthwaite are almost certain to be thrown back in. Moyes has shown he will roll the dice on a half-fit Mykolenko, as he did last week, and Branthwaite remains the defensive bellwether – when he is solid, Everton look organised; when he wobbles, the whole back line creaks.
James Tarkowski will anchor the centre with his usual physical presence, while Ainsley Maitland-Niles offers versatility on the opposite flank, a useful asset against an Arsenal side that loves to overload wide areas and drag full-backs into uncomfortable positions.
In midfield, James Garner becomes crucial. If Everton are to survive long enough to counter, he has to knit their play together and disrupt Arsenal’s rhythm. Around him, Harrison Armstrong, Jack Grealish and Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall provide industry and guile, though all three will likely spend long stretches chasing shadows rather than dictating tempo.
Merlin Röhl, used by Moyes in a more defensive role last week, is expected to reprise that job: plugging gaps, screening the back four, and trying to slow Arsenal’s quick combinations through the middle.
Up front, Thierno Barry stands alone. His task will be brutal and simple: make the ball stick when it comes, win fouls, and offer just enough threat to stop Arsenal’s defenders from camping permanently in Everton’s half.
Bench frustration and untapped energy
The substitutes’ bench tells its own story. Mark Travers provides cover in goal, with Michael Keane and Jake O’Brien as defensive options. In midfield, Hayden Hackney will again be asking himself what more he can do to earn serious minutes. His omission from the starting XI has become a recurring subplot, and every quiet Everton performance only sharpens the question.
Nørgaard, officially back in training, will likely be held in reserve as Moyes tries to rebuild his sharpness and confidence. Out wide, Brennan Johnson, Tyrique George, Charly Alcaraz and Tyler Dibling offer fresh legs and different profiles, the kind of late-game chaos that could be useful if Everton are still alive in the contest heading into the final 20 minutes.
That, in truth, is the challenge: staying alive long enough for those options to matter.
A free hit or a reckoning?
For Arsenal, this is the sort of fixture that defines serious title bids. Champions put away wounded visitors at home. They do it efficiently, without fuss, and without opening the door to jeopardy.
For Everton, the narrative is different. Years of disappointment at the Emirates have lowered expectations to the point where some supporters will travel more in hope than belief. That can be dangerous for a home side that expects to roll over their opponent. It can also be liberating for a team written off before a ball is kicked.
Moyes will talk about organisation, discipline, and taking chances when they come. Arteta will talk about standards and control. Only one of them walks out on Saturday with a result that matches their words.
The other leaves North London with louder questions ringing in their ears.






