Backup Keeper Benjamin Lundt Shines as St. Louis CITY Wins First U.S. Open Cup on Penalties
Reserve goalkeeper Benjamin Lundt stepped up dramatically to lead St. Louis CITY to a U.S. Open Cup final win against Columbus Crew via penalties. The German’s saves brought life to an otherwise uninspired final, underscoring the club’s patient, process-driven approach.
Match Overview
For much of the 90 minutes, Columbus Crew pressed hard and dominated possession, especially during the first 70 minutes. This wasn’t the kind of game St. Louis typically aims for, as coach Yoann Damet prefers controlling the ball rather than sitting back defensively. Yet, his team showed resilience, absorbing pressure before starting to push forward late in the match.
Neither side could find the net in regular time. Roman Burki, St. Louis’s starting goalkeeper, performed well but had to be replaced after suffering a head injury. His replacement, Lundt, maintained solidity between the posts. Both teams seemed locked in similar tactical setups, based around a 3-4-2-1 formation, reflecting their shared coaching lineage under Wilfried Nancy. While Columbus fired more shots overall, only three found their way on target.
The game turned into a battle of endurance, with players battling cramps and stoppages marking intense physical effort. It was fitting that the result came down to penalties, where Lundt’s calm and sharp reflexes made all the difference. St. Louis converted all five of their spot kicks, while Lundt saved two attempts from Columbus, securing the trophy.
Winners and Losers
- Winner: Yoann DametDamet has led St. Louis through a remarkable turnaround in his first full season as head coach. Though he often stresses the importance of daily progress over immediate success, this trophy validates his methods. The club was written off earlier in the year but has now claimed a prestigious title that could herald future triumphs. Damet's focus on teamwork rather than individual stars paid off.
- Loser: Laurent CourtoisCourtois, serving as interim coach for Columbus Crew, faced a tough task without key players like Wissam Abou Ali. Despite a solid tactical plan and strong performances from captain Sean Zawadzki and midfielder Brais Mendez, the Crew lacked a clinical finisher. Courtois's side showed grit but ultimately fell short in the shootout.
- Winner: Benjamin LundtLundt’s performance was the defining factor of the match. Coming off the bench after Burki’s injury, the towering German was mostly quiet in normal time but became the hero in the penalty shootout by saving two crucial shots. His instinctive guessing and quick reactions gave St. Louis the edge needed to claim their first trophy.
- Loser: Rafa NavarroSt. Louis missed the firepower of Navarro, who was cup-tied and unavailable. Signed midseason for $12 million, Navarro had been prolific in MLS play, scoring eight goals in as many games. His absence left a noticeable gap in attack, with no one able to provide the decisive touch in front of goal.
- Winner: Wilfried NancyThe influence of former Columbus coach Wilfried Nancy was clear throughout the game. Laurent Courtois’s tactics reflected Nancy’s style, focusing on building through the thirds and maintaining possession. St. Louis also share this DNA through Sporting Director Core Wray, who worked closely with Nancy. Though the match lacked attacking flair, both teams displayed the defensive discipline Nancy’s teams are known for.
- Loser: The FansThe match was a difficult watch, marked by a tactical stalemate and a lack of clear scoring chances. With only six shots on target combined and no shots during the second half of extra time, the game felt slow and cautious rather than exciting. Fans hoping for an open, high-scoring affair were left disappointed.






