logo

Arsenal's Striker Dilemma: Viktor Gyokeres and the No.9 Debate

Arsenal’s £ big bet on Viktor Gyokeres was supposed to close a chapter, not open a new debate. Signed in 2025 to finally solve the long-running No.9 problem at Emirates Stadium, the Swede delivered 21 goals in his first season across all competitions. On paper, that reads like a solid return.

On the pitch, the argument is still raging.

Arteta has trusted him from the start in just one Premier League game this season. Instead, Kai Havertz has been pushed into the role of central striker, a false nine by background asked to play the very position Arsenal thought they’d fixed. Gyokeres has four goals so far, his tally kick-started in the Community Shield, but he is hardly bullying defences or silencing doubters.

For a club that wants to dominate Europe, that question bites hard: is this enough?

The No.9 that still isn’t there

Arsenal came within a kick of the Champions League last season, only to watch PSG celebrate after penalty shootout heartbreak in the 2026 final. That night underlined everything: the margins, the pressure, the need for someone who lives for the decisive moment inside the box.

Across the continent, the picture is changing. PSG often glide through games with a shape that feels more like jazz than structure. Ousmane Dembele, Desire Doue, Khvicha Kvaratskhelia – all drifting, all interchanging, a front line built on movement rather than a fixed reference point.

Barcelona have gone down a similar road. The echoes of Pep Guardiola’s era still linger: no classic No.9, no obvious spearhead, just a carousel of attacking midfielders and wide forwards cutting into central spaces.

So the question lands at Arsenal’s door: can a team without a ruthless, old-fashioned striker really take down the best of France, Spain and Germany and finally lift that first Champions League trophy?

William Gallas doesn’t think so.

Gallas: “PSG are the exception”

Speaking to GOAL in association with SeatPick, the former Arsenal defender did not dance around the issue.

“I think it's only PSG who can play without a striker,” he said. “They’re the only team that can still win games and win the Champions League without a striker. Luis Enrique has played without a striker who is a real number nine for many years so he conducts that system perfectly.

“For Arsenal and Mikel Arteta, I think he really needs that number nine who can help him win these important games and score that important goal and right now, it looks like they don't have that number nine.”

It is a blunt assessment, and it cuts to the heart of the project. Arteta has built a side that controls matches, that suffocates opponents with structure and intensity. Yet even as defending champions, already five points clear at the top of the Premier League, the suspicion lingers that when the season tightens and the air thins in Europe, they might still lack the killer in the box.

A squad that needs minutes, and motivation

The season will give Arteta chances to experiment, even if one of those avenues has already closed. Arsenal’s Carabao Cup exit to League Two Fleetwood was a jolt, a result that stripped away a competition traditionally used to blood fringe players and keep the wider squad involved.

They will start another FA Cup campaign in 2027. They remain unbeaten in four European fixtures. Borussia Dortmund and Real Madrid loom on the horizon, the kind of epic nights that define reputations and test depth.

For players like Gyokeres, those games should represent opportunity. But when one route to minutes disappears, frustration grows. Gallas knows that dynamic all too well.

“Unfortunately, Arsenal are out of the Carabao Cup now and that can be a good competition to make players happy, to make players feel that they are part of the project, because we know at the beginning of the season, everybody is very excited to fight for their position,” he said.

Then comes the grind.

“Slowly, slowly, when you are fighting, when you are training very hard, and then on the weekend you are not in the starting eleven or you are not on the list for the weekend, slowly, slowly your excitement starts to drop.

“This is especially true in the winter period of November and December and January, you suddenly as a player you are not the same. You go to training but not really with the same motivation because before you even set foot on the training ground, you almost know you won't be in the starting XI for the weekend or you won't be on the list. That is very difficult sometimes for the players.

“That's why they have to be really, really strong and Mikel Arteta, he knows how to communicate with his players, to keep their seasons alive.”

That man-management will be tested now. Keeping a high‑profile striker sharp when he is not the first choice is a delicate job. Keeping him convinced he still has a central role in a title defence and a European charge is even harder.

Arsenal have the points, the platform, the style. What they still lack, in Gallas’ eyes, is the one thing money was meant to buy in 2025: a No.9 who ends the debate, not fuels it.