logo

Alexander Isak: From Criticism to Crucial Goals for Liverpool

Alexander Isak has never been short of critics. Sympathy, though? That’s been in short supply.

Plenty at Liverpool and beyond still haven’t forgiven the way his Newcastle exit unfolded, the strike action that forced the club’s hand and delivered him to Anfield for a nine-figure fee. When he then stumbled through the opening months on Merseyside, there was little patience for context. No proper pre-season. No rhythm. No sharpness. Just a hugely expensive forward who looked nothing like the jet-heeled menace that had once chased Erling Haaland’s crown as the Premier League’s most terrifying No.9.

Then came December 20 at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium. A glimpse of the player Liverpool thought they’d bought. One cool run, one perfectly timed dart in behind, one ice-cold finish from a Florian Wirtz through-ball. That was the blueprint. That was the investment.

A split-second later, it was carnage. Micky van de Ven thundered in with a reckless challenge and Isak’s left fibula snapped. The season, and almost his Liverpool reputation, went with it.

He came back three months on, but the body wouldn’t play along. Muscular issues, niggles, setbacks – all traced back to that missing pre-season. He never found a groove. Never looked free. The numbers told the story: three league goals in 14 appearances. For a striker with his price tag, that’s brutal.

So when the World Cup rolled around this summer, it arrived at exactly the right time for him, even if Liverpool would never call it “perfect” out loud. Sweden leaned on him. He responded. Four goal involvements in North America, one of them scored by him, but the more important figure was the minutes: all but one of them as Sweden fought their way to the round of 32. Game after game, he moved, sprinted, pressed. The legs remembered how to work again.

Still, the doubts lingered as the new Premier League season kicked off. Could he stay fit? Could he handle Andoni Iraola’s intense, front-foot style? Even his first league goal of 2026-27, in a 2-2 draw with Nottingham Forest on August 29, didn’t convince everyone.

“Isak, apart from his goal, did absolutely nothing. He was so poor. He didn’t look interested at all,” the former Liverpool defender told GOAL.

A damning line followed: “He didn’t look like he could carry the shirt.”

For a £100m forward, that’s the kind of assessment that sticks.

Warnock questioned his hunger, his sharpness, his ability to live with the weight of that fee. If this was the refreshed, fully prepared Isak, where was the edge? Where was the menace? The implication was clear: time was running out for excuses.

Then the goals started to arrive.

The Friday after that Forest game, Isak went to Ipswich and dragged Liverpool to their first win of the season with a brace in a 2-0 victory. The dam had cracked. Bournemouth, Brentford, Brighton – he scored in all three morale-boosting wins that followed. Six goals in seven league matches, compared to three in 14 last season. Same player, different animal.

Iraola, though, has never presented Isak as a luxury poacher who can just live in the box.

“He’s a striker that if we can put him in the right positions, if we can provide him with crosses and good situations, he will score the goals,” the Liverpool boss said last weekend.

That part is obvious. But he quickly added the caveat that defines his regime.

“It is also about other things. I will demand other things so we can play well, and if we play well, we are in good positions, the goals will come for him. So, I think he has to contribute to the collective.”

That is where the conversation around Isak still bites. He understands the need to defend from the front in Iraola’s system, yet his work off the ball can look modest next to Lewis Koumas, whose energy and pressing set the standard in that role. Cody Gakpo has already joked that Isak owes him a few assists after the Dutchman teed him up several times earlier in the season, and it wasn’t entirely a throwaway line. For all the goals, the Swede can still drift away from Liverpool’s build-up, operating more as a finisher than a fulcrum.

There are hints, though, of a broader evolution. Bradley Barcola’s arrival has given Isak a winger who reads his runs and feeds his instincts. The Frenchman supplied crucial balls for Isak’s goals against Brentford and Brighton, a pairing that felt less like coincidence and more like the start of something deliberate. No one at Anfield would claim he’s yet reproducing the complete, all-court centre-forward play he showed at Newcastle, but the old, clinical version is reappearing in flashes – and those flashes are starting to decide games.

Across the league, that contrast is becoming uncomfortable for Arsenal.

Mikel Arteta and his recruitment team gambled that Viktor Gyokeres could be a cheaper answer to the Isak question: a powerful, direct striker from Sporting CP who would deliver similar impact without the same transfer outlay. That bet is under scrutiny. Gyokeres only scored his first goal of the current campaign in a Carabao Cup humiliation at Fleetwood Town, a night that also underlined the erratic finishing of Kai Havertz.

Gyokeres offers plenty physically. He runs channels, he battles centre-backs, he stretches defences. But he wastes chances. Too many. Where Isak needs only a couple of touches to flip a match, the Arsenal man often needs several opportunities just to find his range.

Isak is not flawless. He can vanish from games for long stretches, disappearing into pockets of space that never quite see the ball. Right now, though, Arteta would probably accept that trade-off in a heartbeat: a forward who might go quiet for 80 minutes but still has the Haaland-like capacity to end everything with one ruthless movement and one clean strike.

That is the threat looming over Arsenal’s trip to Anfield on Sunday. For all the noise about his past, his price, his patchy first year, Alexander Isak has not lost the one quality Liverpool paid for above all else – the ability to decide a title-shaping match in an instant.